“We are at risk too”: The disparate impacts of the pandemic on younger generations

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in profound global impact. Beyond those acquiring the disease, persons are also affected by physical distancing and additional unprecedented stresses related to financial loss, childcare challenges, and limited healthcare access, among others. It is recognized that aging populations are at elevated risk of adverse outcomes including COVID-related critical illness and death.^1-3 Less well understood are the psychosocial impacts that will undoubtedly outlive the pandemic; understanding at risk groups is essential.^4,5 This study provides preliminary insight into COVID-related psychosocial impacts across generational groups in Canada.

Rates of stress and worry are higher among younger generations including “Millennials” and “Generation Xers” compared to older groups including “Baby Boomers” and the “Greatest/Silent Generations”.^6-8 This transcends to age-related differences in rates of mental disorders, which are elevated in younger compared to older generations.⁹ Charles’ Strength and Vulnerability Integration theory¹⁰ proposes that older adults have elevated strengths in coping with life stressors and consequently exhibit greater emotional well-being.^6,11 However, when faced with unavoidable or inescapable negative events, these age-related strengths are compromised. There are also unique challenges inherent to older adults with multimorbidity during the pandemic, including isolation¹¹ and loneliness, which may be exacerbated by the “digital divide” (i.e., less virtual access)⁵, and may elevate risk of mental health challenges in this context.

Also unclear are the behavioural generational differences during COVID-19. Generally, engagement in preventative health behaviours improves with increasing age and younger generations are at highest risk of engaging in fewer health-promoting behaviours;^12,13 this may translate to engagement in poor health behaviours during the pandemic. Stress and anxiety during COVID-19 may also impact behavioural responses; research suggests elevated concern is associated with adherence to behavioural recommendations and adaptive health behaviours.^14,15,16 However, significantly elevated distress can result in counterintuitive behavioural practices, including maladaptive health behaviours (e.g., increased smoking) or avoidance.¹⁴ This may suggest that younger generations, who are at potentially higher risk of compromised mental health, may exhibit poorer behavioural responses compared to older adults. In support, research on the SARS outbreak revealed that older adults were better able to adapt their coping strategies to the changing environmental context, and engaged in more precautionary health behaviours.^17,18

The current study aims to describe behavioural changes, levels of anxiety, and COVID-related concerns across generational groups using two Canadian population-based surveys conducted between March and May 2020. Preliminary research from a convenience sample of 302 adults from the United States revealed that older adults perceive greater risk of COVID-19 than younger adults, but older men were less worried and endorsed the fewest number of behavioural changes.¹⁹ This preliminary study, however, was limited in its sample size, was demographically homogeneous, and was based in the United States. Across generational groups in Canada, we aim to: (1) report rates of precautions and adaptive and maladaptive health behaviours during the pandemic, (2) assess differences in levels of anxiety, and (3) examine rates of and changes in COVID-related concerns.

Methods

Results

COVID-19-Related Concerns (surveys 1 & 2; table 3)

Within survey 1, members of the Greatest/Silent Generations expressed greater concerns about their own health (51.5%), the health of their household (61.1%), and the health of Canadians (78.8%) compared to other generations. Baby Boomers expressed greater concerns about violence in the home (9.3%) compared to other generations, and Millennials expressed greater concerns about vulnerable peoples’ health (87.5%) and civil disorder (49.1%). There were significant differences in the mean number of concerns according to generation (F(3) = 4.88, p < .01); post-hoc analyses revealed that Generation Xers (5.83) reported a greater number of concerns compared to Baby Boomers (5.44).

View this table:

• View inline
• View popup
• Download powerpoint

Table 3.

COVID-19-Related Concerns According to Generation

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Clinically significant anxiety symptoms according to generation (survey 2: N = 45,989; April 24-May 11, 2020)

Within survey 2, generational trends were maintained but concerns were less common across the majority of domains for each generation, with a few exceptions. For example, concern about maintaining social ties were more common for Millennials and remained similar for Generation Xers and Baby Boomers/Greatest/Silent Generation. There were significant differences in mean number of concerns according to generation (F(2) = 577.54, p < .001); results demonstrated a linear trend with a decreasing number of concerns according to increasing age.

Discussion

Given the unprecedented nature of the COVID-19 pandemic, limited information exists on disparities in impacts across the lifespan. Popular media has referenced differential responses across generations but empirical evidence is lacking. This study represents the first population-based examination of behavioural, cognitive, and emotional responses to COVID-19 across generational groups, using population-based Canadian survey data. Three primary results emerged: 1) overall anxiety and worry are prevalent in response to the pandemic across all generations, 2) there are generational differences in emotional and behavioural responses, and 3) COVID-related concerns appear to be decreasing with time. Although COVID-related worries and anxiety are greatest for younger generations, adaptive health habits were stable across groups, while maladaptive health habits were highest among younger groups. Despite this, COVID-related precautions were also highest among the younger generations, with Generation X exhibiting the highest rate of precautionary behaviour.

Mental health trends were consistent with prior research demonstrating that the youngest generation had the highest rate of clinically significant anxiety (36.0%), followed by Generation X (27.1%), and Baby Boomers/Greatest/Silent Generations (14.5%). Comparably, in prior Canadian research using the GAD-7, only 6.1% of adults ages 65+,²⁹ 18.6% of a large sample of public safety personnel,³⁰ and 15.5% of adults in the Quebec population³¹ scored in the clinically significant level. This suggests that current rates of anxiety in response to COVID-19 are substantially higher than the norm. Disparate trends emerged for specific COVID-related worries; younger generations had a higher mean number of worries relative to older generations. However, the types of worries differed across groups. While older generations were more concerned about health and well-being of themselves, their household, and Canadians in general; younger generations had greater concerns about secondary implications of COVID-19 such as civil disorder, maintaining social ties, family stress, and the ability to cooperate. The trend of overall reduced impact of COVID-19 on older generations’ mental health relative to younger generations is consistent with prior trauma research.³² This is also partially consistent with one recent COVID-19 study that found that older men reported less worry related to COVID-19 compared to their younger counterparts.¹⁹ The reduced mental health impact may be related to adaptive coping and emotional regulation strategies apparent in late life.¹⁰

There were also pandemic-related generational differences in behavioural responses.

Younger generations engaged in a greater number of precautionary behaviours, with Generation X exhibiting the highest level of precautions. Elevated precautions among this group may relate to elevated levels of worry and anxiety³³ compounded by increased responsibilities in caring for both children and older adults. This is exemplified by the elevated rate of “making a plan to care for household members who are ill” (13.4%) and “concern about family stress from confinement” (37.7%) among Generation X compared to other groups. This is also consistent with Barber and Kim who found lower rates of engagement in precautions among older adults.¹⁹

Despite these differences, all groups demonstrated similar levels of adaptive health habits. Conversely, a significant proportion of individuals reported changing weekly habits, many of which would be considered maladaptive, and rates differed across groups. Millennials and Generation X reported increased rates of cannabis and alcohol consumption. This may relate to elevated anxiety symptoms among these younger groups, which is recognized to elicit maladaptive health behaviours in general¹⁴ and in the context of trauma.^34,35 These behaviours should be closely monitored as they may increase the risk for substance use disorders or other health sequelae.³⁶

The two surveys, administered 1 month apart, demonstrate that worries across all age groups appear to decline over time, particularly among older generations. The earlier survey was employed at the early stages of the pandemic in Canada and may have captured acute and elevated concerns related to pervasive uncertainty at that time. Mass media began to display 24/7 coverage of COVID-19, which has been shown to elicit widespread stress in the context of community trauma.³⁷ However, with time, a significant proportion of people likely habituate and adjust to these changes and emotional responses, which has been previously described.³⁸ Prior research has also shown that older adults tend to exhibit greater responsiveness and flexibility in coping strategies over the course of pandemics,¹⁷ which may be reflected by larger declines in worries among older groups.

Despite the strengths of the current study including a large population-based sample of contemporary and timely data, there are limitations. First, these trends are based on self-report as opposed to clinical assessments/semi-structured interviews. Second, given time constraints, Statistics Canada was unable to employ rigorous sampling procedures (for survey 2) which may limit generalizability. Third, both surveys were cross-sectional and therefore longitudinal trends could not be examined. Fourth, this study utilized public access data and therefore groups were aggregated to protect the identity of participants; therefore, there were limitations in how we defined generational groups. Finally, findings were based on Canadian data and trends may not be representative of other countries.

The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in widespread fear and anxiety as indicated by the elevated mental health rates across all generational groups. Clinically significant anxiety ranged from 14.5-36.0%, with Millennials exhibiting the highest levels of both worries and anxiety.

Trends in both precautions and maladaptive behaviours varied according to generation. While members of the Greatest/Silent Generations engaged in the fewest precautionary behaviours, Millennials endorsed the highest number of maladaptive behaviours; interestingly, all generations engaged in similar rates of adaptive health behaviours. One distinction that will be important to further investigate is differentiating adaptive precautions from maladaptive safety seeking behaviours (e.g., excessive precautions in the absence of objective risk) that serve to maintain anxiety long-term.³⁹ Mental health should be carefully monitored across the lifespan, particularly younger adults, as early acute stress responses are predictors for adverse health sequelae.⁴⁰ This is particularly problematic given that younger generations are also coping with greater maladaptive behaviours (e.g., elevated alcohol consumption), further exacerbating risk. Finally, targeted interventions such as media campaigns¹⁶ should be developed to facilitate precautionary behaviours among older populations with the likelihood that active cases will wax and wane over time.