The impact of COVID-19 on Italy web users: a quantitative analysis of regional hygiene interest and emotional response

Introduction

Thanks also to introducing tools for the analysis of the queries popularity such as Google Trends, the Internet has become one of the most important platforms for obtaining valuable data on users’ health and interests [1, 2]. Over time, more and more authors utilized Google Trends and the techniques of use have refined by creating tutorials articles [3]. Alongside the increasing number of users who use the web every day to obtain information on any topic, there is a growing need to control the circulation of the same to prevent fake from affecting public health and economy. For this reason, new branches of science called infodemiology and infoveillance were born [4]. Given the COVID-19 emergency, these two disciplines will provide useful data to researchers to evaluate the impact of the pandemic on people’s lives and welfare, fake news and infodemic monikers spread, as well as people’s attitude towards an unprecedented international issue.

Between the end of February and the beginning of April, Italy was the second most affected country by COVID-19 both in terms of total number of infected and deaths, becoming the epicenter of a shifting pandemic [5]. As evidenced in other studies, an enormous amount of information regarding the novel coronavirus has circulated in the country [6]. Although most of these were moderately infodemic, there was great interest in hygiene and prevention measures. However, no research in the scientific literature available has quantitatively analyzed the impact of COVID-19 on psychological web searches nor thoroughly investigated hygiene-related ones by looking for correlations with the number of cases per region. Since, as shown in other studies, the impact of COVID-19 on the mental and physical health of the Italian population has been devastating, we believe it is of fundamental importance to study the relationship between the trend of health-related queries and the real need for assistance [7]. In fact, this could help scientists estimate the well-being of the population from the trend of web searches.

Methods

We used the Google Trends tool to investigate the Italian netizens’ web interest in the COVID-19 pandemic. As explained in other studies of this type, Google Trends provides normalized values, called relative search volume (RSV), ranging from 0 to 100 in proportion to the popularity of the queries [3]. We searched for specific keywords that recorded high RSVs, helping us both with the items “related queries”, “related topics”, and with the results of another study on the COVID-19 infodemiology in Italy [6]. We focused on three categories of queries: generic news, hygiene, and emotional response related to stress and anxiety. After collecting the data, we looked for correlations with the official data on COVID-19 provided by the Italian Civil Protection Department regarding the number of infected, hospitalized, dead, healed, and swabs [8]. When the trends showed sufficient regularity, we looked for interpolating functions that represented them.

Results

Generic news web interest

The web interest of the Italian users towards COVID-19 was similarly distributed among all regions (ASV = 92,SD = 9) and has dropped over time [Table 1, Figure 1]. Its trend, after the last peak at March 11^th until June 10^th, 2020, is well represented by the exponential function with y₀ = −5.017, SD = 23.5; A₁ = 56.801, SD = 10.6; τ₁ = 0.012831, SD = 0.0122; A = 28.665, SD = 13.6; τ₂ = 0.0995501, SD = 0.0473. The arithmetic mean of all the average daily COD correlations between February 24 and June 10, 2020, is not statistically significant (ρ_best = .17,95% CI: [.15, .19],P=.48). We found significant positive daily COD correlations at the end of February with hospitalized, home isolation and recovered patients, as well as with new, active and total cases, and new and total deaths (ρ_best = .45,95% CI: [.44, .46],P=.05). After that, other significant positive COD correlations occurred only two times [Figure 2]. Significant negative daily COD correlations were found from 8 March onwards; in particular, the one with the number of COVID-19 swab tests reached several significant negative peaks between May and June, 2020 (ρ_best = -.48,95% CI: [-.51,-.45],P = .04). On the contrary, the cumulative COVID-19 web searches – COD correlations maintained significant values until around March 14^th, although they also had a declining trend [Figure3]. In fact, excluding the items “recovered”, “Δ total infected”, and “swabs”, a function representative this correlation (February 24 – June 10, 2020) is y = A + B · (1+e^(C−x)/D), with A = 0.4360, SD = 0.0202; B = −0.34409, SD = 0.022; C = 23.438, SD = 1.26; D = 5.8573, SD = 1.02.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

COVID-19 regional web interest from February 20 to June 10, 2020.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2.

COVID-19 regional daily web interest – official data Pearson’s correlation trends from February 24 to June 10, 2020.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3.

COVID-19 regional cumulative web interest – official data Pearson’s correlation trends from February 24 to June 10, 2020.

View this table:

• View inline
• View popup
• Download powerpoint

Table 1.

COVID-19-related generic news, hygiene, prevention, and negative emotions RSVs. RSV = relative search volume, ASV = average search volume, SD = standard deviation. *South Tyrol is included.

Hygiene and prevention web interest

Web search interest related to disinfectants went from ASV = 5.14 (95% CI: [4.90, 5.38]) in the period January 1 to February 19, 2020, to ASV = 11.09 (95% CI: [8.56, 13.63]) in the period February 20 to June 10, 2020, i.e. it has undergone 115.8% average increase (95% CI: [115.3, 116.3]). Considering the same two periods, web interest related to medical masks and gloves went from ASV = 3.62 (95% CI: [2.88, 4.36]) to ASV = 36.25 (95% CI: [29.97, 42.52]), i.e. it has undergone 901.2% average increase (95% CI: [850.3, 952,2]). From February 20 to June 10, 2020, hygiene web interest made up about 12.6% of COVID-19 one (95% CI: [11.0, 14.2]) but, unlike the latter, its trend remained almost constant until around May 20^th [Figure 4]. Considering the daily web searches, we found significant COD correlation values only in a very few isolated cases [Figure 5]. Finally, regarding the cumulated web searches, we have highlighted significant positive COD correlations from February 26 to March 7, 2020, with all fields except “home isolation” and “swabs” (ρ_best= .43, 95% CI: [. 42, .44],P = .07) [Figure 6]. The differences in the distribution of interest were more important than those on generic news (ASV = 86,SD = 9; ASV = 85,SD = 9) [Table 1].

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4.

Hygiene and prevention regional web interest from February 21 to June 10, 2020.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 5.

Hygiene daily regional web interest – official data Pearson’s correlation trends from February 24 to June 10, 2020.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 6.

Hygiene regional cumulative web interest – COVID-19 official data Pearson’s correlation trends from February 24 to June 10, 2020.

Emotive-psychological well-being web interest

On the web emotional response to COVID-19, we got the following results: nationally, comparing the averages weekly RSVs of the two periods 1 January 2018 - 31 December 2019 and 1 January 2020 - 10 June 2020, we observed a decrease of 3.1% and 16.1% on generic web searches related to stress and depression respectively (95% CI: [-3.0, -2.9], 95% CI: [−16.2, −16.0]) and an increase of 8.1% (95% CI: [8.0, 8.2]) and 20.5%(95% CI: [20.4, 20.6]) of those inherent in fear and anxiety (we point out that the trend related to anxiety had already been growing since December 2019) [Figure 7]. In the second period, the latter had a little increasing daily trend expressed by the equation y = mx, with m = 0.04, 95% CI: [0.00, 0.08]; this shows that general anxiety has not diminished over time, as opposed to the number of new, active and serious cases, and new deceased. From February 20 to June 10, 2020, the web interest in negative emotions made up 4.1% of COVID-19 one (95% CI: [3.6, 4.5]). In the same period, the web interest in negative emotions explicitly related to novel coronavirus made up about 1.4% of that related to COVID-19 (95% CI: [1.2, 1.5]). Regarding the latter, it was only possible to look for COD correlations with the cumulative web interest since the data on the daily web interest was too uncertain. We found cyclically positive significant COD correlations throughout the investigated period [Figure 8]. To support this, web interest in negative emotions has had extremely different distributions across regions (ASV = 55, SD = 41).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 7.

Italy web interest in negative emotions from January 1, 2018, to June 10, 2020.

Discussion

The quantitative investigation of web users’ interests in a crisis moment is a priority aspect to test the effectiveness of online information and the perception of risk by the population. This is the first study to carry out this analysis in Italy, one country most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic in the world. Our results show that interest in the novel coronavirus has exploded only in the presence of two contemporary phenomena: i) the presence of the virus in the nation; ii) a significant number of cases. Even the state of emergency declared on January 31, 2020, due to the case of the two Chinese tourists infected with COVID-19, has caused a very moderate and limited time web interest [10]. We also highlighted a disparity between online searches and the actual perception of the danger: in fact, as shown in other studies and reported by national and international newspapers, the first episodes of racism against the Chinese ethnic group and the so-called “coronavirus psychosis” [6, 11, 12]. Therefore, we believe it is plausible that the analysis of web interest in Italy shows genuine interest only if the issue exceeds a certain severity threshold. We believe that the climate of uncertainty created by the press and by the many conflicting opinions of scientists influenced negatively the perception of the risk linked to COVID-19 in the Italian population; in particular, some have compared it to an influence while others rightly denoted its dangers and critical issues also related to the lack of reliable information [13, 14]. When the problem became national instead, we recorded two peaks in the web queries (February 27, 2020 and around March 14, 2020). Significant correlations between web interest and regions with multiple cases rarely occurred only in the initial phase, i.e. web interest in the novel coronavirus has been linked only to its presence on national soil and nothing more. Since the aforementioned peaks had a maximum duration of about 7 days, we believe that online information is effective only in that time frame. The regional web interest in this topic were very similarly distributed. This leads us to plan two considerations: i) the online information on a problem in its initial phase can heavily influence the thinking of the Italian population; ergo, it is important that those who take on making information online are clear right away; ii) the online information on a problem in its initial phase can have a deep impact on its evolution.

Positive data emerge from the web interest in hygienic precautions, such as disinfectants, masks. In fact, the respective increase of about 115% and 901% compared to the periods preceding the virus signals a drastic change in the netizens’ habits to face the pandemic. We must weigh such a result on the fact that the mean value of these queries corresponds to approximately 13% of all the novel coronavirus-related queries. The lack of long-term correlations with the number of cases and the low variance of the data suggest that the interest was similarly distributed among all regions; this helped to avoid the spread of the epidemic nationwide [Table 1]. Even in this case we have seen two peaks in queries and then a waning interest. This does not mean that the actual interest in hygiene has decreased, since disinfectants, masks, and gloves, have experienced a great increase in sales [15].

General interest in negative feelings such as stress and depression fell during the lockdown (around 3% and 16% respectively). The RSVs of anxiety and fear increased by approximately 21% and 8%, respectively. Therefore, it is plausible that there has been a shift of interest towards the latter. Direct associations between these symptoms of distress and the novel coronavirus made up about 1% of total COVID-19 queries. The data had an incredibly significant variance and high linear correlation values i.e. the interest was much more pronounced in some regions, such as Emilia Romagna, Piedmont, Campania, Lombardy, and Puglia [Table 1]. The inconstant trend of the correlation between cumulative web searches and COVID-19 official data shown in figure 8 suggests that the number of total searches was low, as it was easily influenced day by day. The effects of the novel coronavirus and its lockdown on the mental health of the Italian population have been serious as shown in other studies [7]. Therefore, even a small amount of these types of queries can mean a lot for mental disorders.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 8.

Regional cumulative web interest in negative emotions related to novel coronavirus – COVID-19 official data Pearson’s correlation trends from February 24 to June 10, 2020.

Limitations

Web searches provide quantitative values only for users who use the internet to obtain information on certain topics. All the queries investigated were collected from the Google search engine.

Conclusions

The Italian netizens showed a marked interest in the COVID-19 pandemic only when this became a direct national problem. In general, web searches have rarely been correlated with the number of cases per region; we conclude that the danger, once it arrived in the country, was perceived similarly in all regions. We can state that the period of maximum effectiveness of the online information, in relation to this type of situation, is limited to 3-4 days from a specific key event. If such a scenario were to occur again, we suggest that all government agencies focus their web disclosure efforts over that time. Despite this, we have found cyclical correlations with research related to negative feelings such as anxiety, depression, fear, and stress. Therefore, to identify mental and physical health problems among the population, it suffices to observe slight variations in the trend of related web queries.

Conflict of Interest

None

Source of funding

None

Data availability

All the data related to this study are presented in the manuscript.