Left hemisphere lateralization of epileptic focus can be more frequent in temporal lobe epilepsy surgical patients with no consensus associated with depression lateralization

Introduction

The most common form of focal epilepsy is Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE). Most of the patients are refractory to antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), about 75% presenting resistance to medical treatment [1–3]. Psychiatric comorbidities, such as anxiety disorders, are often expressed among patients with TLE [4–7]. The exact mechanism behind this association remains to be explored; however, the major findings indicate that these comorbidities and TLE share similar neuroanatomic localization [3, 8]. Another factor that remains uncertain and may contribute to anxiety and depressive symptoms in TLE is the side of the epileptogenic focus. Research has documented the prevalence of interictal depression in left-sided seizure foci [9, 10], while others illustrate a tendency for greater depressive symptoms in presurgical right-sided seizure foci patients [11, 12].

Depressive and anxiety symptoms in epilepsy patients are evaluated by the scales and inventories established. A quantitative measure of recurrent and severity of mood symptomatology experienced by them can be recorded by these tests [13, 14]. Neuropsychological functions in TLE patients can also be influenced by antagonist effects such as underlying injury, mood disorders, and AEDs treatment. In this regard, neuropsychological assessments are substantial to comprehend better the impact of those variables on the lives of patients. The interaction between laterality of temporal lobe epilepsy, usage of AEDs, depressive symptoms, and neuropsychological functions remains to be elucidated. For a better comprehension of this association, we proposed a systematic and comprehensive literature review searching for the outcomes of the correlation between these aspects in surgical patients.

Methods

A systematic review was conducted using the methodology outlined in the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviewers [15]. The data were reported following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses [16]. The review protocol was registered under the number CRD42019104443 in the International Register of Prospective Systematic Reviews.

Eligibility criteria

The inclusion criteria for the present review were as follows: articles without language restriction; diagnosis of epilepsy by ECG (Electrocardiogram) or MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging); Psychiatric diagnosis (by scales, interviews, diagnostic manuals – DSM and ICD -10); study design (case series with more than ten patients, retrospective and prospective, clinical, human); unilateral or bilateral temporal lobe epilepsy; surgical patients.

Studies of systematic reviews, letters, and experimental studies; children under 16 years; patients with dysphoria; patients with generalized epilepsy (multiple foci); non-surgical patients were the exclusion criteria. Figure 1 displayed a flowchart of study selection and inclusion.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Summary of evidence search and study selection.

Results

The search retrieved 2971 potentially relevant citations from the electronic databases. By removing duplicate titles, 55 articles were eliminated. After screening titles and abstracts, only 14 articles met the inclusion criteria (Fig. 1). The clinical design approach included prospective (28.5%), retrospective (28.5%), cross-sectional follow-up (21.4%), and cohort (7.14%). Most of them were single-center studies (85.7%).

Overall, 14 surgical studies with TLE were evaluated and DSM/SCID was the main method used for psychiatric diagnosis (PD) (35.7%). However, about 50% of the studies did not employ any kind of PD. Moreover, the neuropsychological evaluation was not explored by most of the studies (71.5%). From 11 studies that portrayed clinical cases of lateralization of the epileptic focus, most of them were found to occur in the left hemisphere (483 patients) (Table 1). Nine studies were evaluated for individual depressive diagnosis and five to anxiety, therefore, from the data analyzed in both situations, no diagnosis was representative in preoperative and postoperative cases (p < 0.05) (Table 2).

Regarding the types of treatment using antiepileptic drugs, most studies failed to report the treatment utilized (57.2%). More details about each study evaluated above are summarized in Tables 3 and 4.

Discussion

Several beneficial outcomes, as reduced seizure frequency, improved quality of life, and mood dysfunction, have been known to be associated with surgical procedures for treating refractory epilepsy [17, 18]. Temporal lobectomy could be a resolution for depression and anxiety symptoms in epileptic patients since the limbic system play a crucial role in increasing the risk of these conditions [19]. Studies documented that for the patients with seizure focus in the temporal lobe, depression symptoms are more frequent as compared to those with an epileptic focus in extratemporal lobe regions, and the epilepsy surgery could resolve the depression symptoms in some of the patients [19]. Reduction in depression symptoms post-surgery has been reported by some studies, especially when patients presented decreased seizure frequency [4]. Contrary to this finding, Meldolesi and colleagues showed that though there was a reduction in anxiety symptoms after epilepsy surgery, depression persisted, even with the decline of seizure frequency in the majority of the patients [20]. Studies also indicated that the diagnosis of depression prior to the surgery did not affect the surgical outcome for seizure control [21,22]. However, Pintor et al. could relate the prevalence of psychiatric symptoms before surgery with the occurrence of psychiatric conditions post-surgery [23]. Furthermore, studies have highlighted the manifestation of anxiety in most of the epilepsy surgery candidates [24]. Anxiety can remain during the first year post-surgery [4] and can depend on the seizure control after surgery [25].

Though a number of treatments are available to reduce seizure frequency, its effect on depression or anxiety symptoms in epileptic patients should also be verified. The AEDs used for the treatment were not mentioned in most of the studies, considered for the present review. However, it is an important aspect since antiepileptic drugs may be responsible for an increase or decrease in depression and anxiety symptoms in epileptic patients [26]. Moreover, some antidepressant drugs may contribute to the alteration of seizure frequency [27]. Besides, it is also important to report any change in the number of AEDs prescribed to the patients after surgery. Prayson and colleagues demonstrated that the quantity of AEDs was reduced in only 28% of the patients after surgery, whereas 58% of patients continued with the same AEDs after surgery [28].

In the present review, the majority of the evaluated studies have shown lateralization of epileptic focus occurred in the left hemisphere. However, no clear consensus is present regarding the association of depression lateralization and epileptic focus. Some studies depicted that depression occurs more frequently after lesions or seizure focus in the left hemisphere [29, 30]. According to Burton and Labar [31], increased depression was reported by patients who were subjected to left temporal lobectomy in comparison to the patients with right temporal lobectomy [31]. Besides, a correlation between the severity of depression and the extension of hippocampus and amygdala resection, especially in left temporal lobectomy, was established by Paparrigopoulos et al. [32]. Furthermore, surgical laterality and location can be predisposing factors for psychological outcomes in epileptic patients post-surgery. Prayson et al. [28] elucidated more significant depression and anxiety symptoms among patients with left temporal lobe epilepsy before surgery as compared to the patients with left frontal lobe epilepsy. On the other hand, Devinsky et al. [33] demonstrated no association between the presence or absence of depression and anxiety and the lateralization or localization of the seizure onset before surgery. Besides, Manchanda et al. also failed to establish any correlation between the laterality of seizure focus and depression symptoms [24].

In this present systematic review, the evaluated data related to individual depressive diagnosis and anxiety, in both situations, no diagnosis was representative in preoperative and postoperative cases. Any kind of psychiatric diagnosis or neuropsychological evaluation was not executed by most of the evaluated studies in this review. The included studies that performed PD the primary method utilized was DSM/SCID. Different methods of depression diagnosis may lead to distinct conclusions and create hurdles in generalizing the outcomes [34]. Besides, some studies have recognized the preoperative depression diagnosis as potential complications in the postoperative seizure outcome of patients with refractory epilepsy [35]. De Araujo Filho and coauthors also demonstrated the absence of depression diagnosis pre or postoperative was associated with favorable seizure outcomes after surgery [36].

Conclusions

The prevalence of psychiatric disorders among refractory epileptic patients undergoing surgical procedures has been documented by various studies. However, no clear association has been elucidated, so far, between lateralization of seizure focus and the existence of depression and anxiety conditions. Surgery is considered the best treatment option for refractory epileptic patients. Determination of the risk of depression and anxiety symptoms in epileptic patients before surgical procedures is important to estimate the efficacy of surgery in the psychiatry episodes and its relation to seizure control. Besides, identification of these symptoms prior to surgery is vital to distinguish those patients who will require a longer specific psychological surveillance after surgery. Thus, rigorous pre- and postoperative evaluation of psychiatry conditions is essential in patients with refractory epilepsy candidates for surgery.

Declarations

Funding Sources

This research did not receive any other specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Abbreviations

TLE

Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

BDI

Beck Depression Inventory

STAI

State Trait Anxiety Inventory

AEDS

Antiepileptic Drugs

BAI

Beck Anxiety Inventory

DSM-III-R

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-III-Revised

SCID

Structured Clinical Interview for DSM

BPRS

Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale

BDI-II

Beck Depression Inventory-II

QOLIE

Quality of Life in Epilepsy

DSM-IV

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV

WAIS-III

Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised-III

MMPI-2

Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-2

BNT

Boston Naming Test

DCS-R

Diagnostikum fu □r Cerebralscha □digung

VLMT

Verbal Learning and Memory Test

QOL

Quality of Life

POMS

Profiles of Mood States