Accurate Prediction of Breast Cancer Survival through Coherent Voting Networks with Gene Expression Profiling

ABSTRACT

We describe a novel machine learning methodology which we call Coherent Voting Network (CVN) and we demonstrate its usefulness by building a 5-years prognostic predictor for post-surgery breast cancer patients based on CVNs. Coherent Voting Network (CVN) is a supervised learning paradigm designed explicitly to uncover non-linear, combinatorial patterns in complex data, within a statistical robust framework. Breast Cancer patients after surgery may receive several types of post-surgery adjuvant therapeutic regimen (endocrine, radio- or chemo-therapy, and combinations thereof) aiming at reducing relapse and the formation of metastases, and thus favouring log term survival. We wish to predict the outcome of adjuvant therapy using just small molecular fingerprints (mRNA) of the patient’s transcriptome. Our aim is to have simultaneously high scores for PPV (positive predictive value) and NPV (negative predictive value) as these are important indices for the final clinical applications of the predictor. A Training-validate-test protocol is applied onto CVN built on patient data from the Metabric Consortium (about 2000 patients). For the testing pool of 82 lymph node positive patients we obtain PPV 0.77 and NPV 0.78 (Odds Ratio 11.50); for the pool of 61 lymph node negative patients we obtain PPV 0.68 and NPV 0.88 (Odds Ratio 16.07). Improved results are obtained on some specific sub-types of BC. For the testing pool of 16 TNBC patients we obtain PPV 1.0 and NPV 0.83 (Odds Ratio 45.00). For the testing pool of 18 HER2+ patients we obtain PPV 0.91 and NPV 1.0 (Odds Ratio 40.00). For the testing pool of 41 Luminal B patients we obtain PPV 0.75 and NPV 0.95 (Odds Ratio 60.00). Effectiveness of the selected fingerprints is confirmed also on several independent data sets (for a total of 601 patients) from the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO).