Fatty acid profiles, cholesterol composition, and nutritional quality indices of 37 commonly consumed local foods in Kuwait in relation to cardiovascular health

Food sampling

Top thirty seven most commonly consumed local foods among Kuwaitis were selected from “Kuwait Total Diet Study” data. The selected foods included 21 foods commonly cooked and prepared at home, and 16 ready-made foods often purchased by locals rather than cooked at home. Each ready-made food was purchased from three different restaurants/confectioneries based on its popularity among Kuwaitis. The most common brands of cream cheese spread (four brands), triangle processed cheese (three brands), and white cheese low fat (one brand “Al-Wafra”) were purchased from retailers.

As for cooked foods, data on the ingredients, their quantities, and cooking procedures were collected based on a field survey of 250 Kuwaiti households. The food recipes were standardized by identifying the foremost ingredients of each recipe and their weight ratio from the total, ensuring that the coefficient of variation (CV) did not exceed 20%. Details on the major ingredients of the 37 foods are given in S1 Table.

The cooked foods were prepared at the Ministry of Health (MOH) kitchen based on the standardized recipes under the supervision of experienced Kuwaiti cooks. All ingredients including water were weighed, and three identical preparations of each food were cooked separately. Foods were cleared of inedible parts, if any, including bones and skin. Each cooked and ready-made food was then homogenized thoroughly in a blender and sampled for moisture analysis. The remaining food sample was dried in a freeze drier (VirTis, Unitop 800L, USA), ground, transferred into airtight bottle containers, labeled, and stored in a deep freezer at -18°C until analysis.

Fatty acid analysis

Total fat content in g/100 g edible portion (EP) of food was determined gravimetrically following Soxhlet extraction (Tecator Soxtec system, HT 1043 extraction unit, Herndon, VA, USA) according to the method given in AOAC [15]. Fatty acids were extracted from each sample in triplicate according to Folch, Lees, and Sloane Stanley [16] with a modification by Segura and Lopez-Bote [17]. Briefly, 0.5 g of freeze dried food sample was homogenized with 20 ml chloroform:methanol (2:1 v/v) solution. The samples were ultrasonicated at room temperature for 15 min. After allowing to settle for a few minutes, the homogenate was filtered. The filtrate was collected in a tube and NaCl solution was added. The tube centrifuged for 20 min at approximately 3000 x rmp. The upper layer of methanol:water was removed, and the lower layer was filtered through anhydrous sodium sulphate and collected in a volumetric flask. The solvent was evaporated under nitrogen, the residual fat was esterified, and methyl esters of fatty acids (FAME) were prepared as described by the American Oil Chemists’ Society (AOCS) Official Method Ce 2-66 [18]. A 0.5 μL esterified sample was injected into a gas chromatograph (GC) (Agilent 6890 Series, Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, CA, USA) coupled with a flame ionization detector (FID). A cyano-polysiloxane (CP-Sil 88 for FAME, part number CP7489) capillary column (100 m × 0.25 mm, 0.20 µm; Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, CA, USA) was used for the FAMEs separation under the following instrumental conditions: injector and FID detector temperatures were 260 and 270°C, respectively, with injector split ratio of 1:50, and carrier gas helium with a constant flow rate of 1.0 mL/min. The initial oven temperature was 80 °C, at which it was held for 5 min, followed by an increase to 220 °C at a rate of 4 °C/min then was held for 5 min, and finally the temperature was increased to 240 °C at a rate of 1 °C/min and was held for 10 min. A 37-component FAMEs standard mixture was used to identify the fatty acids, the mixture contained FAMEs ranging from C4:0 to C22:6. The FAMEs were identified by comparing the retention times of standard peaks with the retention times of sample peaks. The quantification of the fatty acids was performed by the conversion of the peak areas in percentage of the extract using a GC Workstation software. The fatty acid content was reported as percentage of the total fatty acids. In order to compile data in food composition tables, fatty acid data need to be transformed to per 100 g EP on fresh weight basis, to create internationally interchangeable food composition data. The fatty acid composition in g/100 g EP was calculated from the corresponding fatty acid (percentage of total fatty acids), following the method described by Paul and Southgate [19].

Cholesterol analysis

Cholesterol was analyzed in triplicate via GC (Agilent 6890 Series, Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, CA, USA) according to a method described by Naeemi et al. [20]. Each sample was spiked with the internal standard 5-α-cholestane after saponification with a saturated methanolic KOH solution; hexane was then added, centrifuged at 2000 rpm for 2 min, and finally 0.5 μL of the upper layer was injected into the GC for cholesterol analysis.

The GC conditions used in this study were as follows: injector and detector temperatures were 300°C, with injector split ratio of 1:25, and carrier gas helium with flow rate of 1.0 mL/min. The initial oven temperature was 250 °C, the holding time was 2 min, and the temperature rise rate was 3 °C/min.

Fatty acid quality

Fatty acid quality was determined using the atherogenic index (AI) and thrombogenic index (TI) according to Ulbricht & Southgate [21]. The hypocholesterolemic to hypercholesterolemic (H/H) fatty acid ratio index which considers the specific effects of fatty acids on cholesterol metabolism, was determined as described by Testi et al. [22]. The indices were calculated using the following equations: where:

∑MUFA = sum of monounsaturated fatty acids,

∑n-6 = sum of n-6 fatty acids, and

∑n-3 = sum of n-3 fatty acids.

Further indices were calculated as PUFA to SFA (P/S) ratio, and n-3/n-6 fatty acids ratio.

Statistical analysis

Each food sample was analyzed in triplicate for total lipid, fatty acid, and cholesterol composition. Fatty acid data were reported as the mean value on the wet weight of the edible portion of food in g/100 g, and as percentage of the total fatty acids. Cholesterol data were reported as the mean ± standard deviation (SD) in mg/100 g EP of food. The minimum and maximum values for each fatty acid and cholesterol content were interpreted as a measure of range.

Fatty acid profile

Investigated foods in the current study were classified into nine categories: seafood (n=3), soup (n=3), cheese (n=3), rice-based (n=6), desserts (n=11), seed-based (n=2), meat-based (n=4), sandwiches (n=2), and vegetable-based (n=3) (Table 1). The classification of the foods is based on major ingredients in each recipe, as well as the common classification (i.e. cheese, soup, desserts, and sandwiches). All cheese, desserts (except Khabeesa “cooked semolina with oil and sugar” and Aseeda “cooked wheat flour with sugar”), sandwiches, one meat-based food (Arayes “pita bread stuffed with minced lamb”), and one seed-based food (Harda “soft sesame butter, tahini”) were ready-made and purchased from the most popular restaurants and bakeries/confectioneries. The detected fatty acids were classified into four types: SFA, MUFA, PUFA, and TFA. The fatty acid compositions were expressed both as g/100 g EP and as % of the total fatty acids.

Saturated fatty acids

SFA was the most dominant type of fatty acids among analyzed foods (Fig 1). The SFA content was observed with values ranged from 0.01 to 21.85 g/100 g EP (S2 Table). The highest range of SFA content (8.32–21.85 g/100 g EP) and percentage of total fatty acids (62.27–67.33%) was found in cheese. Meat-based foods and sandwiches showed high levels of SFA ranged from 40.65 to 52.09, and 39.43 to 44.91% of total fatty acids, respectively. Knafah (shredded phyllo dough and cheese in sugar syrup) and Gherayba (shortbread cookie) showed high SFA concentrations of 10.96 and 15.95 g/100 g EP, respectively, and high SFA percentage of total fatty acids of 62.92 and 59.98%, respectively (S2 Table and Table 1). The high SFA content of the dessert Gherayba is attributed to the use of ghee in the recipe and to the use of cheese and butter in Knafah.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Fig 1. Concentrations in g/100 g edible portion of food: SFA (saturated fatty acid); MUFA (monounsaturated fatty acid); PUFA (polyunsaturated fatty acid); TFA (trans fatty acid); of 37 commonly consumed local foods in Kuwait.

SFA was the most dominant type of fatty acids among foods, while TFA was found in very little amounts.

According to the joint Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)/WHO [23] and FAO [24] reports, the SFAs with the most determinant effects on blood LDL cholesterol elevation are lauric (C12:0), myristic (C14:0), and to some extent palmitic (C16:0) acids, whereas stearic acid (C18:0) has been shown to reduce total blood cholesterol levels. Lauric acid was detected in trace amounts in all food samples (<0.05% of total fatty acids), whereas, C14:0 proportion was low with values ranging between trace amounts (<0.05%) and 8.2% of total fatty acids, except for cheese dishes (10.70–13.58%) and Knafah (11.77%) (Table 1). C16:0 was the most abundant SFA in 35 of 37 foods. The highest and lowest concentrations of C16:0, 12.02 and 0.01 g/100 g EP, were detected in cream cheese and Shorbat Shaereya (vermicelli soup), respectively (S2 Table). In contrast, the highest and lowest percentage of palmitic acid of the total fatty acids were identified in dessert Darabeel (rolled dough stuffed with sugar and cinnamon; 44.90%) and seed-based food Harda (10.12%), respectively. The C16:0 percent of the total fatty acids was predominant in cheese dishes (36.90–37.58%) and in the following desserts: Baksam (rusk; 32.48%), Baklawa (baklava; 32.68%), Knafah (38.38%), Zalabia (jalebi; 40.87%), and Gherayba (41.24%) (Table 1). Thus, we recommend that these foods be consumed in moderation or the butter and ghee used in desserts preparation can be substituted with unsaturated fatty acids oil. The dominance of SFA in the analyzed foods and of palmitic acid in SFA is consistent with earlier studies on similar groups of foods from Saudi Arabia [25].

Monounsaturated fatty acids

The highest concentration of MUFA (25.66 g/100 g EP) was demonstrated by Harda, followed by Samsamia (sesame bar; 14.07 g/100 g EP) and cream cheese (10.29 g/100 g EP) (S2 Table). MUFA was the most dominant type of fatty acids in only two food samples Keema (minced lamb with peas) and Harda (42.10 and 43.33%, respectively). Oleic acid (C18:1c) was the most dominant MUFA across all 37 food samples. The oleic acid percentage of total fatty acids was the highest in Harda (42.56%), the major ingredient of this food is sesame seeds, known to be high in oleic acid [26].

Polyunsaturated fatty acids

PUFA reduces blood LDL cholesterol, but has an undesirable effect of also reducing HDL cholesterol [11]. As presented in Table 1, PUFA was the most dominant type of fatty acids in vegetable-based foods (54.28–56.69% of total fatty acids), rice-based foods (44.28–55.62% of total fatty acids), and seafood dishes (38.54–52.68% of total fatty acids). Among PUFA, the concentration of linoleic acid (C18:2c n-6) was the highest in all foods, with Harda (22.98 g/100 g EP) and Samsamia (14.35 g/100 g EP) containing the highest levels which were attributed to sesame seeds constituting the major ingredient in Harda and Samsamia recipes. Linoleic acid was the dominant fatty acid in 17 of the 37 foods, which is nutritionally desirable owing to its metabolism at the tissue level, producing hormone-like prostaglandins that aid in reducing blood pressure, preventing gastric ulcers, and relieving nasal congestion and asthma, as well as diminishing platelet aggregation, thus preventing CVD [27]. Linolenic (C18:3 n-3), eicosapentaenoic (C20:5 n-3), and docosadienoic (C22:2 n-3) acids were detected in small quantities (<0.05 g/100 g EP) in all foods. Arachidonic (C20:4 n-6) and docosahexaenoic (DHA; C22:6 n-3) acids were detected in seafood dishes at concentrations of 0.001–0.09 and 0.02–0.51 g/100 g EP, respectively (S2 Table). The arachidonic acid and DHA percentage of total fatty acids detected in seafood dishes varied between traces–2.34 and traces–7.93%, respectively (Table 1). The availability of DHA in seafood dishes is in agreement with other studies [28, 29] pointed to the high levels of DHA in fish.

Trans fatty acids

Trans fats are commonly found in highly processed foods, although natural trans fats produced in animals and foods made from these animals (e.g. milk, meat products) may also contain small amounts of these fats. TFA content investigated in the food samples ranged between traces and 0.45 g/100 g EP, all of which were in ready-made purchased foods and foods of animal origin. The highest TFA concentration (0.45 g/100 g EP) was in a meat-based food Arayes, followed by cheeseburger (0.36 g/100 g EP), and in desserts Baklawa (0.31 g/100 g EP) and Knafah (0.27 g/100 g EP) (S2 Table). The TFA percentage of total fatty acids for the same foods was the highest, with values of 4.78, 2.33, 1.50, and 1.53%, respectively (Table 1). The high TFA content in Arayes and cheeseburger could be attributed to the major ingredient of both of these foods being lamb and beef, respectively; whereas in Baklawa and Knafah, it could be attributed to the use of butter in Baklawa, and butter and cheese in Knafah.

In 2017, Saudi Arabia; a Middle East country with similar lifestyles, dietary patterns, eating habits, nutrition-related health concerns, and nature of foods as the State of Kuwait; implemented 2% and 5% TFA limits for fats and all other foods, respectively [30]. In light of this fact, it is interesting to note that none of the foods analyzed in the present study had TFA >5% of the total fatty acids, whereas the meat-based foods Arayes and cheeseburger had TFA proportion of total fatty acids exceeding 2%.

Overall, TFA has no known health benefits. There is a common understanding that high consumption of TFA has negative health effects, and has been strongly associated with a high risk of CVD [24]. TFA has worse effects on blood cholesterol levels than SFA as it not only raises LDL cholesterol but also lowers HDL cholesterol.

Cholesterol composition

The cholesterol content of the investigated foods varied between 4.42 and 454.79 mg/100 g EP of food (Table 2). Cholesterol was not detected in 19 foods, all of which contained no animal fat, the source of dietary cholesterol, detection limit was <0.05 mg/100 g.

The highest cholesterol content of 454.79 mg/100 g was found in Hameesat Kabdah. This food is based on lamb liver that is known to be rich in cholesterol with 386 mg/100 g EP [31]. The high cholesterol concentrations in Kabab Rubyan (shrimp kebab; 359.17 mg/100 g) and Marag Rubyan (shrimp broth; 212.58 mg/100 g) are attributed to shrimp being the major ingredient in both food recipes. On a fresh weight basis, shrimp contain a high cholesterol concentration of 161 mg/100 g [32]. Cheese dishes (97.13–169.16 mg/100 g), cheeseburger based on beef (123.42 mg/100 g), Shorbat Dajaj based on chicken (103.47 mg/100 g), and Samak Maleh based on fish (86.75 mg/100 g) contained relatively high cholesterol levels. Among desserts, five dishes contained relatively low levels of cholesterol, Baklawa (4.42 mg/ 100 g), Gherayba (10.10 mg/ 100 g), Qatayef (dumpling filled with mixed nuts; 15.32 mg/ 100 g), Halwa (sweet wheat starch; 33.21 mg/ 100g) with the highest concentration of 56.60 mg/100 g in Knafah, that could be attributed to cheese and butter in the recipe. Other foods containing lower cholesterol levels were Keema, Arayes, Madhrooba (crushed wheat with lamb), and Aish Fagae ma laham (rice with truffles and lamb), all of which contained varying amounts of lamb. The cholesterol levels in meat-based foods analyzed in this study were higher than those reported for similar Saudi Arabian and Omani meat-based foods [25, 33].

Fatty acid quality

Foods with low PUFA to SFA (P/S) ratios have been considered as undesirable in the diet, as they induce elevated levels of blood cholesterol, which contribute to an increased risk of CVD and cancers. In order to maintain a healthy cardiovascular status, P/S values higher than 0.45 are desirable [13, 34]. As presented in Table 3, the P/S ratios for meat-based foods (0.10–0.42), cheese dishes (0.01–0.04), desserts (Gherayba 0.12, Knafah 0.08, Baklawa 0.25,Darabeel 0.21, and Zalabia 0.19), cheeseburger (0.40), soup (Shorbat Harees (soup of peeled wheat with lamb) 0.05, and Shorbat Dajaj (chicken soup) 0.31) were all <0.45, which is considered nutritionally unhealthy. The remaining foods had higher P/S ratios (>0.45) and can thus be said to have good fat content for human nutrition concerning the balance between PUFA and SFA.

A balanced n-3/n-6 fatty acid ratio has positive effects on decreasing the risk of CVD and cancers [35]. The n-3/n-6 fatty acid ratios below 4.0 were recommended by the Department of Health of the United Kingdom [36]. The n-3/n-6 ratio of all foods examined in this study (0.00 and 0.26) were within the recommendations (Table 3). Although, recent studies by Marventano et al. and FAO/WHO [23, 37] have suggested that there might not be any impact of n-3/n-6 fatty acid ratio on human health.

An atherogenic and/or thrombogenic food is one that has the potential to induce platelet aggregation, which might stimulate CVD, and is thus considered less nutritionally beneficial. The SFAs, C12:0, C14:0, and C16:0 are considered atherogenic and thrombogenic as many studies have shown that they have a cholesterol-raising effect that may induce platelets aggregation [38]. Thus, foods with higher concentrations of these fatty acids have higher atherogenic (AI) and thrombogenic indices (TI).

AI and TI values were calculated in the present study, these values indicate the potency of foods to stimulate platelet aggregation, and lower values indicate better nutritional quality of food. AI and TI values were the highest for cheese dishes, and ranged from 2.11 to 2.84, and 3.18 to 4.03; respectively (Table 4). The AI and TI values were variable for desserts, AI values ranged from 0.17 in Khabeesa and 2.31 in Knafah, while TI values ranged from 0.37 in Khabeesa and 3.29 in Knafah. The high AI and TI values for Knafah were attributed to the presence of around 50% C14:0 and C16:0 SFA. Soup was the third highest food group with AI ranging from 0.36–1.12, and TI from 0.66–2.61. AI ranged between 0.61–0.78 and TI between 1.30–1.58 for sandwiches, 0.51–0.66 and 1.29–2.07 for meat-based food, 0.18–0.55 and 0.32–0.58 for seafood, and 0.14–0.70 and 0.33–1.13 for rice-based food. A low AI of 0.15 was recorded for all vegetable-based foods, as well as low TI values varied between 0.33 and 0.35. AI for seed-based Harda and Heso (garden cress and fenugreek seeds stew) was the lowest among all foods investigated in this study, with values of 0.12 and 0.14, respectively; and the lowest TI among all foods was 0.29 for Heso. This is attributed to low C14:0 and C16:0 SFA and high MUFA and PUFA levels in Harda and Heso.

Contrary to AI and TI, foods with higher H/H indices are more nutritionally desirable [39]. The highest H/H (8.04) was recorded for Harda. The H/H range for the different foods examined in this study from the highest to lowest values were: rice-based foods (2.14–6.99), vegetable-based foods (6.55–6.85), Heso (6.79), seafood (2.25–5.87), desserts (0.65–4.78, except Khabeesa with H/H 6.29), soup (1.22–3.39), meat-based foods (1.62–2.04), sandwiches (1.46–1.86), and cheese dishes with the lowest H/H values (0.55–0.68). The AI, TI, and H/H values may indicate that the consumption of seed-based, vegetable-based, rice-based, and seafood dishes analyzed in the present study is potentially healthier, in terms of the fatty acid quality, for humans than that of cheese, desserts, sandwiches, and meat-based foods.