A Checklist for Assessing the Methodological Quality of Concurrent tES-fMRI Studies (ContES Checklist): A Consensus Study and Statement

Hamed Ekhtiari, Peyman Ghobadi-Azbari, Axel Thielscher, Andrea Antal, Lucia M. Li, A Duke Shereen, Yuranny Cabral-Calderin, Daniel Keeser, Til Ole Bergmann, Asif Jamil, Ines R. Violante, Jorge Almeida, Marcus Meinzer, Hartwig R. Siebner, Adam J. Woods, Charlotte J. Stagg, Rany Abend, Daria Antonenko, Tibor Auer, Marc Bächinger, Chris Baeken, Helen C. Barron, Henry W. Chase, Jenny Crinion, Abhishek Datta, Matthew H. Davis, Mohsen Ebrahimi, Zeinab Esmaeilpour, Brian Falcone, Valentina Fiori, Iman Ghodratitoostani, Gadi Gilam, Roland H. Grabner, Joel D. Greenspan, Georg Groen, Gesa Hartwigsen, Tobias U. Hauser, Christoph S. Herrmann, Chi-Hung Juan, Bart Krekelberg, Stephanie Lefebvre, Sook-Lei Liew, Kristoffer H. Madsen, Rasoul Mahdavifar-Khayati, Nastaran Malmir, Paola Marangolo, Andrew K. Martin, Timothy J. Meeker, Hossein Mohaddes Ardabili, Marius Moisa, Davide Momi, Beni Mulyana, Alexander Opitz, Natasza Orlov, Patrick Ragert, Christian C. Ruff, Giulio Ruffini, Michaela Ruttorf, Arshiya Sangchooli, Klaus Schellhorn, Gottfried Schlaug, Bernhard Sehm, Ghazaleh Soleimani, Hosna Tavakoli, Benjamin Thompson, Dagmar Timmann, Aki Tsuchiyagaito, Martin Ulrich, Johannes Vosskuhl, Christiane A. Weinrich, Mehran Zare-Bidoky, Xiaochu Zhang, Benedikt Zoefel, Michael A. Nitsche, Marom Bikson
doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.12.23.20248579

Article Information

doi 
https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.12.23.20248579
History 
  • October 27, 2021.

Article Versions

Copyright 
The copyright holder for this preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made available under a CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International license.

Author Information

  1. Hamed Ekhtiari1,#,
  2. Peyman Ghobadi-Azbari2,3,
  3. Axel Thielscher4,5,
  4. Andrea Antal6,
  5. Lucia M. Li7,8,
  6. A Duke Shereen9,
  7. Yuranny Cabral-Calderin10,
  8. Daniel Keeser11,12,
  9. Til Ole Bergmann13,14,15,
  10. Asif Jamil16,
  11. Ines R. Violante17,
  12. Jorge Almeida18,19,
  13. Marcus Meinzer20,21,
  14. Hartwig R. Siebner4,22,23,
  15. Adam J. Woods24,
  16. Charlotte J. Stagg25,26,
  17. Rany Abend27,
  18. Daria Antonenko21,
  19. Tibor Auer17,
  20. Marc Bächinger28,29,
  21. Chris Baeken30,31,32,
  22. Helen C. Barron25,26,
  23. Henry W. Chase33,
  24. Jenny Crinion34,
  25. Abhishek Datta35,36,
  26. Matthew H. Davis37,
  27. Mohsen Ebrahimi3,
  28. Zeinab Esmaeilpour38,
  29. Brian Falcone39,
  30. Valentina Fiori40,
  31. Iman Ghodratitoostani41,
  32. Gadi Gilam42,
  33. Roland H. Grabner43,
  34. Joel D. Greenspan44,
  35. Georg Groen45,
  36. Gesa Hartwigsen46,
  37. Tobias U. Hauser47,48,
  38. Christoph S. Herrmann49,50,51,
  39. Chi-Hung Juan52,53,
  40. Bart Krekelberg54,
  41. Stephanie Lefebvre55,
  42. Sook-Lei Liew56,57,58,59,
  43. Kristoffer H. Madsen4,60,
  44. Rasoul Mahdavifar-Khayati2,
  45. Nastaran Malmir3,
  46. Paola Marangolo61,62,
  47. Andrew K. Martin20,63,
  48. Timothy J. Meeker64,
  49. Hossein Mohaddes Ardabili65,66,
  50. Marius Moisa67,
  51. Davide Momi68,
  52. Beni Mulyana1,
  53. Alexander Opitz69,
  54. Natasza Orlov70,71,72,73,
  55. Patrick Ragert74,75,
  56. Christian C. Ruff67,
  57. Giulio Ruffini76,77,
  58. Michaela Ruttorf78,
  59. Arshiya Sangchooli3,
  60. Klaus Schellhorn79,
  61. Gottfried Schlaug80,
  62. Bernhard Sehm75,
  63. Ghazaleh Soleimani81,
  64. Hosna Tavakoli3,82,
  65. Benjamin Thompson83,84,85,
  66. Dagmar Timmann86,
  67. Aki Tsuchiyagaito1,
  68. Martin Ulrich45,
  69. Johannes Vosskuhl49,
  70. Christiane A. Weinrich87,88,
  71. Mehran Zare-Bidoky3,89,
  72. Xiaochu Zhang90,
  73. Benedikt Zoefel37,91,92,
  74. Michael A. Nitsche16,93 and
  75. Marom Bikson38
  1. 1Laureate Institute for Brain Research, Tulsa, OK, USA
  2. 2Department of Biomedical Engineering, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran
  3. 3Iranian National Center for Addiction Studies (INCAS), Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
  4. 4Danish Research Centre for Magnetic Resonance, Centre for Functional and Diagnostic Imaging and Research, Copenhagen University Hospital Amager and Hvidovre, Hvidovre, Denmark
  5. 5Department of Health Technology, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
  6. 6Department of Neurology, University Medical Center Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany
  7. 7Computational, Cognitive and Clinical Imaging Lab, Division of Brain Sciences, Department of Medicine, Imperial College London, UK
  8. 8UK DRI Centre for Care Research and Technology, Imperial College London, UK
  9. 9Advanced Science Research Center, The Graduate Center, City University of New York, New York, NY, USA
  10. 10Research Group Neural and Environmental Rhythms, Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics, Frankfurt, Germany
  11. 11Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Hospital LMU Munich, Munich, Germany
  12. 12Department of Radiology, University Hospital LMU Munich, Munich, Germany
  13. 13Neuroimaging Center (NIC), Focus Program Translational Neuroscience (FTN), Johannes Gutenberg University Medical Center, Langenbeckstr. 1, 55131, Mainz, Germany
  14. 14Leibniz Institute for Resilience Research, Wallstraße 7, 55122, Mainz, Germany
  15. 15Department of Neurology and Stroke and Hertie Institute for Clinical Brain Research, Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany
  16. 16Department of Psychology and Neurosciences, Leibniz Research Centre for Working Environment and Human Factors, Dortmund, Germany
  17. 17School of Psychology, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Surrey, Guildford, UK
  18. 18Proaction Lab, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, University of Coimbra, Portugal
  19. 19CINEICC, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, University of Coimbra, Portugal
  20. 20Centre for Clinical Research (UQCCR), The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
  21. 21Department of Neurology, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany
  22. 22Department of Neurology, Copenhagen University Hospital Bispebjerg and Frederiksberg, Copenhagen, Denmark
  23. 23Institute of Clinical Medicine, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark
  24. 24Center for Cognitive Aging and Memory, McKnight Brain Institute, Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA
  25. 25Wellcome Centre for Integrative Neuroimaging, University of Oxford, FMRIB, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, UK
  26. 26Medical Research Council Brain Network Dynamics Unit, Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Oxford, Mansfield Road, Oxford, UK
  27. 27Section on Development and Affective Neuroscience, National Institute of Mental Health, Bethesda, MD, USA
  28. 28Neural Control of Movement Lab, Department of Health Sciences and Technology, Zurich, Switzerland
  29. 29Neuroscience Center Zurich, University of Zurich, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
  30. 30Department of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology, University Hospital Ghent, Belgium
  31. 31Department of Psychiatry, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, University Hospital Brussels, Belgium
  32. 32Eindhoven University of Technology, Department of Electrical Engineering, the Netherlands
  33. 33Department of Psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
  34. 34Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, University College London, London, UK
  35. 35Research and Development, Soterix Medical, New York, USA
  36. 36The City College of the City University of New York, New York, USA
  37. 37MRC Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
  38. 38Department of Biomedical Engineering, The City College of New York of CUNY, New York, NY, USA
  39. 39Northrop Grumman Company, Mission Systems, Falls Church, VA, United States
  40. 40Department of Clinical and Behavioral Neurology, IRCCS Santa Lucia Foundation, Rome, Italy
  41. 41Neurocognitive Engineering Laboratory (NEL), Center for Engineering Applied to Health, Institute of Mathematics and Computer Science (ICMC), University of Sao Paulo, Brazil
  42. 42Systems Neuroscience and Pain Laboratory, Division of Pain Medicine, Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative, and Pain Medicine, School of Medicine, Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA, USA
  43. 43Educational Neuroscience, Institute of Psychology, University of Graz, Austria
  44. 44Department of Neural and Pain Sciences, University of Maryland School of Dentistry, Baltimore, MD, USA
  45. 45Department of Psychiatry, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany
  46. 46Lise Meitner Research Group Cognition and Plasticity, Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences, Leipzig, Germany
  47. 47Max Planck University College London Centre for Computational Psychiatry and Ageing Research, University College London, London, UK
  48. 48Wellcome Centre for Human Neuroimaging, University College London, London, UK
  49. 49Experimental Psychology Lab, Cluster of Excellence “Hearing4all”, European Medical School, University of Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany
  50. 50Neuroimaging Unit, European Medical School, University of Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany
  51. 51Research Centre Neurosensory Science, University of Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany
  52. 52Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, National Central University, Taoyuan, Taiwan
  53. 53Cognitive Intelligence and Precision Healthcare Research Center, National Central University, Taoyuan, Taiwan
  54. 54Center for Molecular and Behavioral Neuroscience, Rutgers University-Newark, Newark, New Jersey, USA
  55. 55Translational Research Centre, University Hospital of Psychiatry, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
  56. 56Chan Division of Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California, USA
  57. 57USC Stevens Neuroimaging and Informatics Institute, Department of Neurology, Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California, USA
  58. 58Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California, USA
  59. 59Division of Biokinesiology and Physical Therapy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California, USA
  60. 60Department of Applied Mathematics and Computer Science, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
  61. 61Department of Humanities Studies, University Federico II, Naples, Italy
  62. 62Aphasia Research Lab, IRCCS Santa Lucia Foundation, Rome, Italy
  63. 63Department of Psychology, University of Kent, Canterbury, UK
  64. 64Department of Neurosurgery, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland
  65. 65Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences Research Center, Ibn-e-Sina Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
  66. 66Student Research Committee, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
  67. 67Zurich Center for Neuroeconomics, Department of Economics, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
  68. 68Krembil Centre for Neuroinformatics, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH), Toronto, Canada
  69. 69Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
  70. 70Department of Psychosis Studies, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, King’s College London, London, UK
  71. 71Athinoula A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA
  72. 72Department of Radiology, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China
  73. 73Department of Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Cracow, Poland
  74. 74Institute for General Kinesiology and Exercise Science, University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany
  75. 75Department of Neurology, Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences, Leipzig, Germany
  76. 76Neuroelectrics Corporation, Cambridge, Massachusetts, MA, USA
  77. 77Neuroelectrics Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
  78. 78Computer Assisted Clinical Medicine, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Mannheim, Germany
  79. 79neuroConn GmbH, Ilmenau, Germany
  80. 80Neuroimaging-Neuromodulation and Stroke Recovery Laboratories, Department of Neurology, Baystate-University of Massachusetts Medical School, and Department of Biomedical Engineering, Institute of Applied Life Sciences, UMass Amherst, MA, USA
  81. 81Department of Biomedical Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
  82. 82Department of Cognitive Neuroscience, Institute for Cognitive Sciences Studies, Tehran, Iran
  83. 83School of Optometry and Vision Science, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
  84. 84School of Optometry and Vision Science, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
  85. 85Centre for Eye and Vision Research, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
  86. 86Department of Neurology and Center for Translational Neuro- and Behavioral Sciences (C-TNBS), Essen University Hospital, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
  87. 87Department of Cognitive Neurology, University Medical Center Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany
  88. 88Department of Neurology, University Medical Center Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany
  89. 89Shahid-Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran
  90. 90Department of Psychology, School of Humanities & Social Science, University of Science & Technology of China, Hefei, China
  91. 91Centre de Recherche Cerveau et Cognition (CerCo), CNRS, Toulouse, France
  92. 92Université Toulouse III Paul Sabatier, Toulouse, France
  93. 93Department of Neurology, University Medical Hospital Bergmannsheil, Bochum, Germany
  1. ↵#Corresponding Author:
    Hamed Ekhtiari, MD, PhD, Laureate Institute for Brain Research, 6655 South Yale Ave. Tulsa, OK 74136, Tel/fax: 918.502.5100, Email: hekhtiari{at}laureateinstitute.org
Back to top
Posted October 27, 2021.
Download PDF

Supplementary Material

Data/Code
Email
A Checklist for Assessing the Methodological Quality of Concurrent tES-fMRI Studies (ContES Checklist): A Consensus Study and Statement
Hamed Ekhtiari, Peyman Ghobadi-Azbari, Axel Thielscher, Andrea Antal, Lucia M. Li, A Duke Shereen, Yuranny Cabral-Calderin, Daniel Keeser, Til Ole Bergmann, Asif Jamil, Ines R. Violante, Jorge Almeida, Marcus Meinzer, Hartwig R. Siebner, Adam J. Woods, Charlotte J. Stagg, Rany Abend, Daria Antonenko, Tibor Auer, Marc Bächinger, Chris Baeken, Helen C. Barron, Henry W. Chase, Jenny Crinion, Abhishek Datta, Matthew H. Davis, Mohsen Ebrahimi, Zeinab Esmaeilpour, Brian Falcone, Valentina Fiori, Iman Ghodratitoostani, Gadi Gilam, Roland H. Grabner, Joel D. Greenspan, Georg Groen, Gesa Hartwigsen, Tobias U. Hauser, Christoph S. Herrmann, Chi-Hung Juan, Bart Krekelberg, Stephanie Lefebvre, Sook-Lei Liew, Kristoffer H. Madsen, Rasoul Mahdavifar-Khayati, Nastaran Malmir, Paola Marangolo, Andrew K. Martin, Timothy J. Meeker, Hossein Mohaddes Ardabili, Marius Moisa, Davide Momi, Beni Mulyana, Alexander Opitz, Natasza Orlov, Patrick Ragert, Christian C. Ruff, Giulio Ruffini, Michaela Ruttorf, Arshiya Sangchooli, Klaus Schellhorn, Gottfried Schlaug, Bernhard Sehm, Ghazaleh Soleimani, Hosna Tavakoli, Benjamin Thompson, Dagmar Timmann, Aki Tsuchiyagaito, Martin Ulrich, Johannes Vosskuhl, Christiane A. Weinrich, Mehran Zare-Bidoky, Xiaochu Zhang, Benedikt Zoefel, Michael A. Nitsche, Marom Bikson
medRxiv 2020.12.23.20248579; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.12.23.20248579
Twitter logo Facebook logo LinkedIn logo Mendeley logo
Citation Tools

Subject Area