SOUTH AMERICAN INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES AND BODY MASS INDEX: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS

Introduction

Obesity is a new pandemic of the 21st century. Currently, more than 1.9 billion adults are overweight and at least 700 million of them are obese (1, 2). In Chile, general population has progressively increased the average of Body Mass Index (BMI) during the last four decades going from normal to overweight (3). The main challenge related to obesity is the risk to suffer Cardiovascular Diseases (CVDs) (2). CVDs are the leading cause of general mortality and disability worldwide (1).

Obesity is the result of a positive energy balance, determined at least by both environmental and genetic factors. Interestingly, individuals within ethnic-based ancestry communities, share both environmental and genetic features (4-8). Specifically, previous reports have explored the relationship between ethnicity and obesity (9-12). For instance, it was showed the relationship between Mapuche ancestry, a native of South America ethnicity, presented the lowest prevalence of Type 2 Diabetes (T2DM) with 1.4%. In the other hand, a North American indigenous group, The Pima community, showed the highest T2DM prevalence reaching 50% of them (13). Mapuche indigenous group represent the vast majority of all the Chilean Indigenous population with 87% of the total indigenous population followed by Aymara indigenous community (4). These communities are highly concentrated in the north (Aymara), and the south (Mapuche) of Chile (7). Until now, there are more than 20 years of cross-sectional BMI reports of Mapuche and Aymara communities. However, these reports have been inconclusive and sometimes contradictories. For this reason, our objective was to identify the relationship between Mapuche and Aymara groups and BMI and obesity.

Methodology

Systematic review and Meta-analysis conducted in Pubmed, LILACS, Scielo, Web of Science and Scopus databases using a mixed strategy-key words: mapuche OR aymara AND (BMI OR “Body Mass Index” OR obesity OR weight). Two authors, CPJ and NFM, independently identified cross-sectional and longitudinal studies published before February 02, 2021, that reported BMI. We used the World Health Organization criteria of obesity to adults: BMI ≥ 30.

Results

Systematic Review results

Figure 1 is a schematic representation of search, inclusion, and exclusion of articles. As we collected all the available reports, we analyzed the Systematic Review by subgroups. Due to the difference of the adults and children criteria to perform the diagnosis of obesity, and to reduce clinical heterogeneity, we divided the data obtained into two parts. The first part (Table 1) is data from children and adolescent (6 to 15 years old) and the second part from adolescents and adults (Table 2). Most of the studies identified as adults using the 15 years old as lower age criteria. We excluded 65% of the articles because repeated on different databases and 30% were excluded by Inclusion/Exclusion criteria (Table 3, Fig 1). The remaining 19 articles (Table 1, 2) describe BMI of 1,764,024 individuals.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Meta-analysis results

To explore the relationship between ethnicity and BMI, we compared BMI of Indigenous and non-indigenous. We identified that Indigenous Children showed a lower BMI than Non-Indigenous Children (Fig. 2a). However, we found no difference within BMI adults (Supplementary Fig. S1a).

Also, we explored the relationship between living areas and BMI. We compared the BMI of Indigenous people living in Rural areas and Indigenous people living in Urban areas. We identified that Indigenous people living in rural areas showed lower BMI than those living in urban regions (Fig. 2b)

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

To explore the relationship between gender and BMI, we compared BMI between men and women among indigenous people. We identified that Aymara and Mapuche Women presented higher BMI than Indigenous Men (Fig. 2c).

Finally, to investigate whether ethnicity could represent a risk factor for obesity, we performed am Odds Ratio analysis. We used positive case of obesity among adult groups. We identified no differences in obesity Odds Ratio between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities (Fig. 2.d).

Discussion

A constant positive energy balance unavoidably leads to increase BMI and finally to develop obesity. In particular, a positive energy balance is the results from a disparity between energy expenditure and caloric intake (18). This energy conservation equilibrium is conditioned at least by both, the environment (19) and genetic factors (20). Interestingly, people within ancestral ethnic groups share worldview, environmental and genetic features (21) influencing lifestyle and health beliefs (22). Over centuries, most of the indigenous groups worldwide have changed their dietary patterns and lifestyle, once new foods have been introduced or integrated into the traditional food systems by settlers and immigrants. For many years, indigenous groups have lost their access to natural resources and to traditional foods, and have been dislocated from their original place (23). Together, these changes led to a rapid change in the way that they obtained food, facilitating the adoption of unhealthy eating habits (24). As a result, nowadays those native people have been showing the same dietary related-health problems as non-indigenous people, including overweight, obesity, comorbidities, and eating disorders (25).

In some countries, as observed in Australia, indigenous people have social and health disadvantages compared to non-indigenous, what it is important to be considered in the epidemiologic reports on their BMI and eating-related behaviors (27). Independent of body weight gain, the westernization of indigenous health includes the higher consumption of calorically dense foods, increased sodium intake, and lowered nutritional intake of fiber. A study conducted in Panama, observed that 85% of Kuna Indian adults reported eating fast food at least one time weekly, 47% reported eating fried food daily, and 11% reported eating junk food daily (28). With this information, the dietary pattern changes in the last decades should be evaluated in Chilean indigenous as well, throughout validated questionnaires in enough size of a sample.

Beyond the availability of western industrialized foods, the power of choice and of purchasing must be considered in the eating pattern studies with indigenous people. Among Kuna Indians from Panama, for example, those with low-moderate income levels eat junk food and sodas less often; however, they also consume fish and fruits less frequently than those categorized as poor (28). The power of the food manufacturing and social media seems to be extremely relevant for the dietary choices as well.

When thinking about nutrition, it is crucial to consider the meaning of food for each person or group. For indigenous people, the traditional cultivation practices of their food were mostly developed based on continuous observation of the natural life cycle of plants and their connection with the respective environment and ecology (24). It means that they have a spiritual connection with the food, which has also been broken along history. Besides, the healthy eating habit does not include only the food quality but also external factors, like availability for cooking or eating, knowledge for doing healthy choices, and each of this factors is influenced by environmental and cultural changes observed throughout globalization, economic growth, and urbanization, which have been resulting in a more westernized lifestyle (26). In this review, we found that specifically in Mapuche and Aymara, Chilean indigenous groups, there are differences in the risk of obesity development according to gender, age, and social conditions. Indigenous children have a lower BMI than non-indigenous children, as well as rural adult indigenous compared to urban ones. On the other hand, indigenous women have higher BMI when compared to indigenous men. One of the included studies from children showed a larger sample size (Bustos et Munoz, 2009), so a meta-analysis was applied considering all studies in a fixed effect model (Fig. 2a), and another meta-analysis considering a random effect model (Supplementary Fig. 1b).

The Chilean population has three main genetic ancestry contributions: Indigenous (44%), European (52%) and African (4%) (14). Mapuche indigenous group represent the vast majority of all the Chilean Indigenous with 87% of the total indigenous population followed by Aymara indigenous community (4). Aymara and Mapuche surnames have higher Indigenous genetic load, so to determine genetic ancestry in Chilean population, surnames are extremely effective (14). For example, individuals with two Aymara surnames ensure 99.7% of Indigenous polymorphisms contribution, and 0.3% load of European contribution (14). For this reason, we used surname validation to separate indigenous from non-indigenous data.

Previous reports showed Mapuche children presented lower incidence of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus when compared with non-Indigenous (29). In fact, the presence of Indigenous surname is suggested as a protective factor for T2DM. On the other hand, Aymara rural population that migrated to the urban areas, increased the prevalence of T2DM from 2 to 7% and Rural Mapuche from 4% to 8% (30).

Remains pending for future studies to investigate the relationship between Mapuche and Aymara obesity and Cardiovascular Diseases, as well as the effect of urbanization of Chilean Indigenous groups and Cardiovascular Diseases.

Limitations

Meta-analyzes presented high statistical heterogeneity and evidence level IV, and then to avoid misleading recommendations new longitudinal research could be required.

Ethics

The study does not require ethical approval because the systematic review is based on published research and the original data are anonymous.

Conflict of interests

The authors declared that they have no conflicts of interest to this work.