Do Assisted Living Facilities That Offer a Dementia Care Program Differ from Those That Do Not? A Population-Level Cross-Sectional Study in Ontario, Canada

INTRODUCTION

Dementia affects more than half of all residents housed in assisted living facilities. ^1–3 Older adults living with dementia are more likely to experience injuries requiring acute care, be diagnosed with pneumonia, and encounter difficulties with eating. ^4,5 Care for dementia is expensive and a widely cited reason for older adults requiring placement in a nursing home. ^6–9 Specialized care for older adults living with dementia, such as a dementia care program, has demonstrated reductions in acute health service use and long-stay transitions to a nursing home. ^8,10

Assisted living facilities are referred to as retirement homes in the province of Ontario, Canada. Similar to assisted living facilities in the United States that are regulated at the state-level, ¹¹ retirement homes are regulated by an independent, not-for-profit regulator (i.e., Retirement Homes Regulatory Authority [RHRA]) in Ontario since 2011. ¹² The retirement home sector in Ontario has a resident capacity equivalent to that of its nursing home sector (i.e., more than 70,000 older adults), ¹² which demonstrates that it is a sizeable, important sector providing supportive care to older adults. Unlike nursing homes, residency in a retirement home is exclusively financed through private, out-of-pocket payments by residents and/or their family caregivers. ^12–14

Much of the literature on dementia care in assisted living facilities addresses health service use among residents living with dementia, managing staff, and state-level regulations for dementia care. ^1,11,15–17 Studies explicitly investigating the characteristics of retirement homes or assisted living facilities that provide specialized care for dementia (i.e., a dementia care program), and how these characteristics compare to those that do not, are absent. The findings from such studies are important for identifying case mix and examining scope and breadth of care for older adults with complex care needs. A growing proportion of residents of assisted living facilities live with dementia, ¹⁸ and improving the understanding of dementia care programs in assisted living facilities contributes to informing the sector, community-based dementia care, and national dementia care strategies. The objective of this study is to identify the characteristics of licensed assisted living facilities that provide a dementia care program compared to assisted living facilities that do not provide such a program in Ontario, Canada.

METHODS

Data

A list of all licensed assisted living facilities in Ontario in 2018 was obtained from the public register of the RHRA and imported to ICES (n = 757). The postal code of each assisted living facility was linked to Statistics Canada’s Postal Code Conversion file, which is a specialized macro for use with health system administrative datasets containing postal codes. This macro is based on 2016 Census information, flags communities with a population less than 10,000 individuals as rural, and includes related data from Canada Post Corporation. ²⁰ Nineteen assisted living facilities (n = 19) were removed from the analysis because of missing facility-level and postal code data.

RESULTS

There were 738 licensed assisted living facilities in Ontario in 2018 (n = 738). Of these, 123 provided a dementia care program (16.7% versus 83.3% no dementia care program), and almost all were located in an urban area (92.7% versus 82.6% no dementia care program) (Table 1). Nearly half of these assisted living facilities had a resident capacity of 140 or more (44.7% versus 21.6% no dementia care program) and had more than 115 suites (46.3% versus 20.8% no dementia care program). All assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program also provided nursing services, meals, assistance with bathing and hygiene, and administered medications (n = 123). Many of the standardized differences between assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program and those that did not exceeded 10%, which indicated that assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program were systematically different from those that did not. ²²

Assistance with bathing and hygiene, provision of meals, administration of medication, and nursing services were removed from the adjusted model because of collinearity, and there was no evidence of multicollinearity in the adjusted model (i.e., variance inflation factors equal to or greater than a value of 10). ²⁵ The deviance goodness-of-fit statistic was not statistically significant. After adjusting for facility characteristics and regulated care services, the prevalence of a dementia care program was almost three times greater in assisted living facilities with 115 or more suites (Prevalence Ratio [PR] = 2.78, 95% Confidence Interval [CI] 1.09 to 7.07) compared to assisted living facilities with 41 or fewer suites (Table 2). The prevalence of a dementia care program was nearly three times greater in assisted living facilities that provided assistance with feeding (PR = 2.91, 95% CI 1.98 to 4.29), and the prevalence of a dementia care program was almost twice as great in assisted living facilities that provided medical services (PR = 1.78, 95% CI 1.00 to 3.17), compared to assisted living facilities that did not provide these care services.

DISCUSSION

Assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program were systematically different from those that did not provide such a program. Specifically, assisted living facilities in Ontario that provided a dementia program had large resident capacities, many suites, and provided, at a minimum, nursing services, meals, assistance with bathing and hygiene, and administered medications. The prevalence of a dementia care program in an assisted living facility was greater in assisted living facilities where assistance with feeding and medical services were also provided.

More than 90% of assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program were located in urban communities. Consistent with existing literature, this finding raises important equity considerations for older adults living with dementia in assisted living facilities located in rural and remote regions. ²⁶ Rural assisted living facilities house fewer older adults and are more likely to have deficiencies in care provision than urban ones, including challenges with retaining appropriate care staff and resources to meet the needs of residents. ²⁷ The use of videoconferencing and other information technology resources to provide dementia care should be considered to improve access to care for individuals living with dementia in rural and remote areas. ²⁸

Most assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program had capacity for more than 140 older adults and had more than 115 suites. Current practices for designing settings specifically for older adults living with dementia emphasize larger spaces that are not characteristic of institutionalized congregate care, ²⁹ and the presence and statistically significant association of many suites in assisted living facilities that provide a dementia care program aligns with the literature. In addition, this may indicate that many assisted living facilities that provide a dementia care program are large complexes, likely attributed to chains.

Given the challenges that older adults living with dementia face with respect to eating, ⁵ it is expected that assistance with feeding would be a prevalent care service offered alongside a dementia care program in an assisted living facility. Moreover, the complex and intersecting care needs of older adults living with dementia, which includes polypharmacy, ³⁰ underscores the need for a physician to monitor and evaluate the care plan. As such, the prevalence of medical services in assisted living facilities that offer a dementia care program is also expected.

As the assisted living sector is privately financed in Ontario, this study makes an important contribution to the literature to define the sector by modeling facility-level characteristics associated with the provision of a dementia care program. The findings are relevant to clinicians and policymakers actively considering dementia care options in communities to support older adults living with dementia and their caregivers. Family caregivers and consumers of assisted living services will also be interested in these findings to inform their decisions for care.

A limitation to this study is that the fees older adults residing in assisted living facilities pay each month and per care service could not be included in the adjusted model. This is due, in part, to the inability to capture this information in existing administrative health system data. Moreover, these data are not publicly available on the websites of assisted living facilities, through their member associations, or available to the RHRA through regulatory reporting requirements. Another limitation is that this study is descriptive; as such, no causal or temporal claims can be made about the associations between the facility-level characteristics of assisted living facilities and the provision of a dementia care program. As with all secondary analyses of data, the data used in this study are susceptible to misclassification bias.

CONCLUSION

This study identified and compared facility-level characteristics of licensed assisted living facilities that provided a dementia care program to those that did not in Ontario, Canada in 2018. Assisted living facilities that offered a dementia care program housed more older adults and provided more care services. Future research might consider investigating the underlying differences in populations between residents of these facilities and their health outcomes attributed to care services provided in assisted living facilities.