Episodic memory deficits are associated with impaired insight in traumatic encephalopathy syndrome: Initial findings of the SNAP-CTE study

1 Introduction

Patients with traumatic encephalopathy syndrome (TES) and the pathological correlate, chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), experience a neurodegenerative disorder (1). As with other types of dementia, in which diagnostic tools are not definitive (2), TES requires verification at autopsy to confirm the presence of CTE (2,3). The pathognomic neuropathological lesion is the accumulation of hyperphosphorylated Tau in neurons and astrocytes, in an irregular distribution around blood vessels at the depths of sulci in the neocortex (4). While CTE has been mostly reported in American football players (5), it has also been found in other sports including soccer (6), professional wrestling, hockey (3) and in Australian-based football (7,8). However, the incidence and prevalence of a TES, as per criteria (1), and the association between concussion/subconcussion burden and TES or CTE is not yet evidenced in Australia. During life, these athletes typically experience concussive and subconcussive head trauma across different sports or non-sporting circumstances, which may overlap.

TES has been characterized to include cumulative head trauma beyond two years; correlating to progressive and delayed subjective and objective features; support by emotional dysregulation; behavioral changes; and motor disturbance, that are otherwise unaccounted for (1). The consideration of this relatively new differential subtype of dementia has not formed part of a traditional neuropathological examination at autopsy (9) nor have typical panels of comorbid cerebral pathology across longitudinal studies (10,11).

Although there is a clear need for neuropathological biomarkers to identify CTE, what is also needed is a clearer neuropsychological profile of this dementia. There is a growing body of literature investigating whether multiple concussive or subconcussive events contribute to long-term neuropsychological impairment in athletes (12,13). Studies assessing the prevalence of cognitive impairment indicate that clinically diagnosed mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is more frequent in contact-sport athletes than would be expected, according to population estimates (14) or when compared to age-matched, non-contact, sport controls (15). Survey data, from retired American football players, indicates that concussion history is associated with both clinically diagnosed MCI and subjective memory impairments (16). Self- and spouse-reports of impairments, consistent with MCI, suggest MCI may occur at a higher prevalence in former contact-sport athletes than would be expected by population estimates (17). This means that former players of contact related sports are more likely to show signs of MCI, compared with the general population. Such athletes also perceive themselves as having greater executive dysfunction, when compared to normative data (18) and age-matched non-contact sport athletes (19). This suggests some insight into the symptoms experienced. The literature remains equivocal as to whether these subjective concerns reflect objective cognitive impairments that can be detected on formalized neuropsychological measures.

Episodic memory, considered the encoding, retention, and active retrieval of specific contextual information, is influenced by MCI (20) and intelligence quotient (IQ) (21,22). Memory is supported by three processes: encoding (the intake and organization of information); consolidation (the storage of information); and retrieval (accessing the information) (23). A prominent study of sporting related RC/SCI (n = 35), as compared with single-impact head trauma (n = 35) or healthy controls (n = 20), found that both injury groups showed significant consolidation and retrieval deficits, whereas the single-impact head trauma group showed greater difficulty encoding (23). Although, it is unclear which aspects of episodic memory deficits are related to CTE. Other studies have found that athletes with a history of concussion, compared to controls or athletes without concussion, perform worse on tasks of episodic memory (14,24–26). One study that compared retired football players with three or more concussions to those with fewer than three concussions found no difference in their performance on memory testing (20). However, the two groups did demonstrate different neural recruitment patterns, which suggested that the retired players with a history of three or more concussions may have functional inefficiencies in memory networks. Therefore, it is important to investigate all aspects of episodic memory including Auditory Memory Index, Visual Memory Index, Immediate Memory Index, and Delayed Memory Index in a cohort of retired athletes to determine which elements (namely encoding, consolidation, or retrieval) are impaired and how they differ from other types of dementia.

Many investigations have assessed the association between concussion history and cognitive decline to establish a dose-response frequency. It has been shown that reductions in executive functioning, episodic memory, and information processing occur in repetitive head trauma. Former athletes who sustained their last sports-related concussion in environments of potential subconcussive burden, over 30 years prior, have demonstrated significantly poorer performance on tasks of episodic memory and response inhibition (26) or significantly impaired performance in visuomotor reaction time, spatial working memory, associative learning, and intra-extra dimensional shift (27,28), compared to healthy former athletes with no history of concussion. More research is needed to determine if there is a dose-dependent effect of mild Traumatic Brain Injury (mTBI) and exposure to repetitive head trauma related to CTE.

As with other forms of dementia, impaired insight may be a key feature when considering a patient’s risk of TES/CTE. Loss of insight is a lack of concern or unawareness of the consequences of symptoms and occurs independently of other psychological mechanisms of the denial of symptoms (29). Although a loss of insight might be indicative of frontotemporal dementia (29), it has also been reported in people with CTE (3,30,31).It is important to determine the extent of loss of insight in people with CTE and how this affects the progression of TES. A discrepancy between carer and patient reported number, type, or severity of symptoms, suggestive of lack of insight by patients into their illness, can have diagnostic and therapeutic implications (32,33).

These findings commence the work of the symptomatology, neurocognitive, and pathophysiological changes in CTE (SNAP-CTE) study, which assesses in-life clinical, radiological, neurophysiological, and neuropsychological characteristics across the spectrum of sporting and non-sporting repetitive head trauma in the Australian population. The larger aim of this project is to identify future biomarkers of disease, and to understand neuropathological and neuropsychological correlates. The current paper aims to determine the baseline neuropsychological characteristics of both active and retired contact and collision sporting participants extending upon the work by Pearce et al. (27,28) which was limited to cognitive outcomes. The primary variable of interest was the difference between IQ predicted and actual scores on the WMS-IV. It was hypothesized that differences between predicted and actual scores, in favor of IQ, would be both significant and clinically unusual. An additional aim was to investigate whether the participants’ level of insight or alcohol use is associated with their cognitive ability and memory. It was hypothesized that insight, as obtained on collateral history from the main carer, is impaired in TES, and that insight is important in determining a neurodegenerative picture as part of a systematic approach to the detection and diagnosis of younger-and older-onset dementia (34,35). It was also hypothesized that more severe episodic memory impairment would be associated with reduced insight.

2 Method

3 Results

Nearly all of the participants included in the study participated in sport (as can be seen in Table 1) with most engaging in a sport that would have involved contact or collisions between athletes or head impact to the ground (e.g., Rugby League/Union/Australian Football League, soccer, and boxing). The potential for whiplash as a form of repeated head trauma was noted. Participation in these environments was for a total period of greater than 10 years, with the years of potential exposure ranging from 11 to 50 years (average age of contact sport commencement was M = 8.2 years old SD = 3.5 year). Years of education completed ranged from 8 to 22 years (M = 12.7, SD = 3.1).

4 Discussion

This was the first Australian study to assess the full spectrum of neuropsychological changes in a group of RC/SCI patients who met criteria for TES compared to normative data. There was support for the hypothesis, such that there were differences between the participants predicted IQ scores and actual IQ scores in various facets of episodic memory. Participants in this cohort performed significantly worse on measures of auditory, visual, immediate, and delayed memory compared to a normative sample. Previous alcohol use disorders may exacerbate disease progression. Participants with impaired or absent insight had poorer verbal comprehension compared with the preserved insight group. Participants with absent or impaired insight had a larger discrepancy between predicted and actual scores on measures of auditory memory, compared to the other two groups. Mood disturbances were higher in the absent/impaired insight group compared to the preserved insight group. Participants with absent or impaired insight had less years of exposure but many more reported concussions, however the skew of the data meant that when examining the median number of reported concussions, this difference reduced. 78.5% of the sample were under the age of 65 yet reporting to a neurologist with concerns about their cognitive functioning. This is in stark contrast to the 0.1% of the Australian population who are currently suffering dementia and are under the age of 65 (39,42) suggesting that RC/SCI is associated with early onset dementia.

Although the severity of the behavioral and psychological disturbance was assessed qualitatively, rather than quantitatively, the cohort were consistently described to have impairment at first neurological consultation. Examples include: paranoid ideation, tendency of anger or rage, and cognitive impairment. Carers consistently reported troubles with irritability, social demeanor, anger, and physical rage accompanying memory impairment that were consistent with neuropsychological findings. These behavioural and psychological disturbances have been similarly described in the review by Montenigro et al. (36). Also, it is likely that alcohol use may be contributing to the neurodegenerative processes of RC/SCI, yet it is unclear if alcohol use exacerbates the progression of disease or if alcohol is a confounding variable. Further investigation is required to determine the true impact of alcohol use as related to RC/SCI and TES.

The value of this study is that it integrated measurement of intellect, working memory, and episodic memory. The study considered performance on tests of working memory and episodic memory relative to norms, rather than to a control group, which could have inherently differed in terms of intellect and by extension, memory. Performance on measures of encoding and retention were impaired relative to predictions derived from IQ. Performance on tests of working memory, which represents one aspect of attention, was not impaired. These findings extend recent reports (23,44) of an impairment of episodic memory in this population and contribute to the literature by demonstrating a significant disparity between the individual’s IQ and memory (45). These findings cannot be explained by reference to poorly matched groups or other methodological limitations. The findings add to the growing body of literature indicating that this group experiences measurable and significant cognitive impairment.

While this study had a small sample, the cohort is suggestive of neurocognitive issues occurring much earlier than anticipated with a traditional dementia onset – including younger onset dementia (34). There was a 12-point difference, on average, in this group between the predicted Auditory Memory Index and the actual result. There appeared to be a trend that number of years of education, may have a protective effect on Auditory Memory Index scores. Given the small sample size, this should be investigated further.

There seemed to be no clear available demographic factors amongst the cohort that increased their likelihood of sustaining a concussion, except for a small positive trend regarding years of play. This relationship between has also been found by Rafferty et al. (46) who noted that playing more than 25 matches increased the likelihood of receiving a concussion. It did appear that alcohol use disorder, alcohol use, and binge drinking, whether concurrent or historic did have either an exacerbating or confounding role within concussion/subconcussion and TES. Further investigation is required to determine the true nature of alcohol use within the disease progression of TES due to exposure to concussive events. Alcohol use disorder or binge use may be reactive to the emergence of other psychological or cognitive symptoms, consistent with described ‘self-medication’ by some within our cohort. It may also be secondary to behavioral dysregulation as a result of cognitive impairment and TES, or contribute to further cognitive behavioral impairment. Alcohol use is now interpreted not only as a cause of TBI but a secondary disorder after TBI, as well as a predictive factor for outcome (47). Although no patients were diagnosed, those with active alcohol use disorders were provided prophylactic thiamine towards the prevention of Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome. An alcohol-related dementia cannot be excluded as contributing to cognitive impairment, however the presence of comparable impairment across those with or without a background alcohol history in the current cohort would favor RC/SCI as a causal factor.

One of the central limitations of the study is the self-selection bias of individuals who volunteered to participate in this behavioral research and the typical characteristics of participants such as greater years of education and higher IQ scores (48,49). Further, it is likely that only those concerned with their cognitive ability are seeking treatment from a neurologist. This self-selection bias may have affected the results. The social desirability of participating in a research study for many athletes often typically derives from a strong personal interest in the results of the study (50), with many acknowledging a concomitant desire to contribute to a body of knowledge that will contribute to both awareness and intervention/prevention of the issue under investigation. As a result, athletes presenting to behavioral research may not be representative of the general sporting population. Additionally, the number of concussive episodes in the sample was largely based on the experience of the patient and their family and is subject to include recall bias. Further investigation would be needed to exclude recall bias and other noted confounding variables. Concussive events in contact sport have historically been considered a “normal” aspect of play, being largely under-evaluated and under-declared (51). This may bias the retrospective recollection of such incidents and some studies have not investigated history of concussion as a predictor variable as they could not confidently ascertain the number of concussions experienced by each athlete (15).Cognitive insight was measured subjectively by both the participant and their carer/spouse. Future research should employ a more objective measure of cognitive insight. This study was underpowered and as a result, we could only report on trends in the data and not control for confounding variables, such as alcohol use.

5 Author Contributions

Dr Mobbs had full access to all the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis.

Study concept and design: All authors.

Acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data: All authors.

Drafting of the manuscript: All authors.

Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: All authors.

Administrative, technical, or material support: Teunisse

Study supervision: Mobbs, Batchelor