T Cell Positive B Cell Negative Flow Cytometry Crossmatch (FCXM): Frequency, HLA-Locus Specificity, and Mechanisms Among 3073 Clinical FCXM Tests

Background A T cell positive and B cell negative (T+B-) flow cytometry crossmatch (FCXM) result remains a conundrum since HLA-class I antigens are expressed on both T and B cells. We investigated the frequency, HLA specificity of the antibodies and mechanisms for the T+B- FCXM result.

Methods We analyzed 3073 clinical FCXM tests performed in an American Society of Histocompatibility and Immunogenetics accredited histocompatibility laboratory. The sera associated with the T+B- FCXM were also tested for donor HLA IgG antibodies using LABScreen™ single antigen assays.

Results Among the 3073 FCXM tests, 1963 were T-B-, 811 were T-B+, 274 were T+B+, and 25 were T+B-. IgG antibodies directed at donor HLA-A, B, or Cw locus determined antigens (DSA) were identified in all 25 sera and the summed mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of DSA ranged from 212 to 53,187. Correlational analyses identified a significant association between the summed MFI of class I DSA, and the median channel fluorescence (MCF) of T cells treated with the recipient serum (Spearman rank correlation, r_s=0.34, P=0.05) but not with the MCF of B cells (r_s=0.23, P=0.24). We identified that differential binding of anti-HLA antibodies to T cells and B cells and the B cell channel shift threshold used to classify a B cell FCXM are potential contributors to a T+B- FCXM result.

Conclusions Our analysis of 3073 FCXM, in addition to demonstrating that HLA antibodies directed at HLA-A, B or Cw locus are associated with a T+B- result, identified mechanisms for the surprising T+B- FCXM result.