A cross-sectional survey of burnout in a sample of resident physicians in Sudan

Background

Burnout syndrome (BOS) was first described by Freudenberg in 1974 [1]. In the 11^th revision of the International Classification of Diseases, BOS has been classified as an occupational phenomenon. It was defined as “A syndrome regarded stemming from continuous work stress that has not been properly managed”[2]. Burnout is characterized by three sub-dimensions; high emotional exhaustion, an increase in the mental distance from the profession; high depersonalization, a skepticism about the career; and a sense of decreased professional achievement [3].

Evidence suggests that healthcare workers suffer from high levels of BOS [4–6] with trainee physicians being at increased risk of BOS compared to other healthcare workers [7, 8]. Among trainee physicians, several occupational and individual factors have been recognized. However, it is uncertain which factors are the most significant in promoting the development of BOS [9].Work-related factors vary among different medical departments, which might suggest that there are certain fundamental disparities in working environments that can be linked to BOS among these populations [9]. BOS also appears to be influenced by payment models, with physicians who only receive incentive or performance-based pay have considerably higher burnout rates than salary paid physicians. [10, 11] BOS is influenced by the organizational context such as negative leadership behaviors and inadequate interprofessional collaboration, as well as possibilities for growth and social support for physicians [12]. BOS is also linked to poor work conditions, increased work demands, work-life imbalance, postgraduate training requirements interfering with personal life, and lack of senior support[9]. physicians’ burnout is not only financially costly, but also has a slew of other consequences, leaving Medicine is a clear example of such consequences [13]. In addition, depression, marital complications, medical errors, substance abuse, and suicidal behavior might occur [14]. Such consequences have detrimental impacts on healthcare organizations, physicians, and the quality of patient care provided [13].

The Sudan Medical Specialization Board (SMSB) is the professional training organization responsible for managing and delivering medical and health specialized programs in Sudan [15]. Sudan has been struggling to coordinate between human resources for health policies and the overall health planning. Because of the lack of coordination between the health authorities –represented by the Federal Ministry of Health- and medical training sector – represented in SMSB – there has been an imbalance between the training and production of health professionals in certain professions [16]. In addition, the mass migration of qualified health workers due to the economic crisis has left Sudan with a severe shortage in terms of qualified trainers. Moreover, the privatization of the health sector during the previous regime in Sudan has made the remaining qualified practitioners much less available for the education and training in teaching hospitals, which in turn affected the quality of medical training [17].

Despite being founded in 1995, the SMSB has just started paying less than 100 $ per month salary to resident physicians in 2021. At the same time, doctors accepted by training programs have to pay annual training fees to the SMSB, posing extreme financial burden on resident physicians and forces them to work extra-hours in private hospitals or clinics to cover their daily living expenses. This in turn affects their training quality and the time they have for academic achievement, which pose further risk for stress and burnout [18]. The training period ranges from four to seven years depending on the chosen specialty. For a considerable portion of the training period, a resident physician would have to work in other state hospitals in Sudan, away from their homes and families due to the SMSB random distribution of trainees. This scenario suggests extreme psychological and mental health impacts among resident physicians in Sudan that warrants urgent investigation to propose effective remedies. The purpose of this study was to estimate the prevalence rate of burnout and its associated factors in a sample of Sudanese resident physicians.

Material and Methods

Results

The sociodemographic and work-related characteristics of respondents are shown in Table 1. A total of 208 resident physicians with mean age of 29.99 ± 3.01 years participated in the present study (69.3% response rate). More than half of respondents were females (56.7%), single (59.6%) and senior resident physicians (50.5%). Most of participants were medicine specialty residents (29.8%). More than one third reported working for more than 24 hours per single duty (32.7%) (Table 1).

The prevalence of burnout syndrome and its dimensions among resident physicians are shown in Table 2. 70.7% of resident physicians suffer from a high level of burnout on the dimension of emotional exhaustion, while 44.2% reported high levels on depersonalization and 73.1% experienced a sense of decreased professional accomplishment. Overall, 86.1% met the criteria for burnout in at least one dimension, and 13.9 % in all three dimensions.

Parameters associated with burnout are shown in table 3. There were significant differences in the levels of emotional exhaustion (EE), depersonalization (DP) and the overall burnout among different specialties, with the Pediatric resident physicians showed higher overall burnout [mean ± SD, 3.19 ± 0.86 (P<0.001)], higher EE [mean ± SD, 4.36 ± 1.26(P<0.001)], and higher DP [mean ± SD, 3.09 ± 1.32) (P<0.001)]. Burnout, EE and DP were significantly associated with the working hours per single duty; with physicians working for more than 24 hours per a single duty, has experienced higher levels of burnout, EE and DP (P<0.001). However, there was no significant differences exist in the level of professional accomplishment related to respondents’ sociodemographic and work-related characteristics. Additionally, there were no significant differences noted in the levels of burnout and its three dimensions among different age groups, gender, years of experience, or marital status of resident physicians (Table 3).

Discussion

This was a cross-sectional study designed to assess the prevalence of burnout syndrome and its related factors in a sample of resident physicians in Sudan. The results of the current study showed 13.9% prevalence rate of burnout among the participants (Table 2). Similar to a study conducted among resident physicians in Greece, in which 14.4% of residents met the criteria for burnout [23]. Additionally, a cross sectional survey in Tunisia concluded that 17.14% of resident physicians had a high level of burnout [28]. Another study in Syria [35] reported 19.3% prevalence rate of burnout syndrome among resident physicians.

In comparing the reported prevalence rate of burnout to existing literature, most cross-sectional studies of burnout syndrome have showed higher prevalence of burnout syndrome among resident physicians in other countries, compared to the results of the current study in Sudan (presented in Table 4). This could be explained by that most of these studies had used the short and abbreviated version of The Maslach Burnout Inventory, which was reported to overestimate the prevalence of burnout syndrome among resident physicians [37]. More importantly, the prevalence rate of burnout reported in the present study results is similar to other studies of burnout among other clinicians and health personnel in Sudan [38, 39], lending support to our findings.

In the analysis of parameters linked to burnout syndrome and its dimensions, there were significant differences noted across specialties with pediatric trainee suffer higher levels (Table 3). In support to this finding many other studies showed that pediatric resident with a higher risk, and suffer higher levels, of burnout syndrome [40–44]. Additionally, burnout rate was positively associated with working hours per duty of resident physicians. This finding was supported by results of a study conducted among resident physicians in Saudi Arabia which established the positive association between the resident duty working hours and burnout syndrome[45]. Moreover, there were no significant differences in burnout rates related to sociodemographic factors residents, age groups, gender, years of residency experience marital status (Table 3). A similar findings was reported in previously research of burnout among resident physicians in South Africa [46] and USA[47].

Limitations

The current study doesn’t assess neither the level of stress, awareness of coping strategies nor job satisfaction among resident physicians in Sudan to avoid a long questionnaire. Hence, the selection of explanatory variables wasn’t theoretically grounded. However, the study was able to provide preliminary evidence regarding prevalence rate of burnout syndrome among resident physicians in Sudan. Since the study was conducted in Gezira state only, due to lack of sufficient resources for a nationwide survey, the results of study cannot be generalized to resident physicians in other states of Sudan.

Conclusions

The study revealed high prevalence of burnout syndrome among the sample of resident physicians in Sudan, with the pediatric registrars being especially vulnerable. There was a significant difference in the level of burnout according to respondents’ working hours per duty. More studies are required to investigate the level of stress, awareness level of coping strategies, and job satisfaction among resident physicians in Sudan and to examine the association of these factors with burnout syndrome.

Statements and Declarations

Conflict of interest statement

Authors declare no conflict of interest.

Authors contributions

Conceptualization: [Yasir Ahmed Mohamed Elhadi, and Abdelmuniem Ahmed]; Data curation, Formal analysis and investigation:[All authors], Writing - original draft preparation: [Yasir Ahmed Mohamed Elhadi, Elhadi B. Salih, Osman S. Abdelhamid, and Mohamed Hayder Hamid Ahmed)]; Writing - review and editing: [All authors]; Supervision: [Noha Ahmed El Dabbah].