Effectiveness of targeted antenatal family planning information provision on early postpartum family planning uptake in Kisumu county: Study protocol for a Simple Randomized Control Trial

Problem Statement

Overlooking the contraceptive needs of postpartum women constitutes missed opportunities in the health care system. Inter-birth interval of at least three years can prevent poor maternal, perinatal and neonatal outcomes and afford women socioeconomic benefits of family planning (FP). The unmet need for FP in the postpartum period remains unacceptably high and far exceeds the FP unmet need of the rest of the women of reproductive age (7,12). Despite observed advances in access to Reproductive, Maternal, Neonatal and Child Health (RMNCH) services in Kenya in recent decades, only 25% of women in Kenya had adopted postpartum family planning (PPFP) by six months, and 35% at one year. This points to feeble progress when it comes to effective postpartum contraceptive services integration (13,14). The study region, Nyanza, posts the shortest median postpartum abstinence with one of the shortest inter-birth intervals nationally. Further, the mean number of children in Kisumu county by the time a woman is 25-40 years is higher (5.6) than the national average (5) (14). Equally, Kisumu County has low (63%) postpartum care provision including PPFP, compared to other Counties that were studied (80%)(11).

Justification

Routine Antenatal services offer frequent points of contact for providers and pregnant women. These contacts are vital opportunities for information giving, counselling and behavioural contracting to address the contraceptive needs of postpartum women (15). However, there no structured FP information giving, counselling and behavioural contracting to ensure earliest uptake of PPFP and there is still paucity of evidence that this structured integration can work. Likewise, evidence is often weak or incomplete particularly regarding studies that explore the desires, intentions, and priorities of women or couples related to PPFP which may differ across settings and demography. Correspondingly, there has been inadequate exploration of operationally-feasible ways to integrate PPFP information giving and counselling into existing ANC services. This gap of limited number of methodologically rigorous Randomized Control Trials that give a detailed description of tested interventions and of how these were implemented is what this study intends to bridge.

The study will therefore examine the effectiveness of targeted antenatal family planning information provision on Postpartum Family Planning uptake by a rigorous but simple randomized control trial that can be feasibly adopted in ANC practice if proven to be clinically superior. Kisumu County, therefore, will be a suitable site for this study as it has outcomes that point to low early postpartum family planning uptake. Postpartum FP uptake will form a basis for conclusion as to whether the models of PPFP service provision proposed in the trial are clinically superior to the routine practice.

Study Aim

Broadly, the researcher intends to examine the effectiveness of targeted antenatal family planning information provision on early postpartum family planning uptake in Kisumu County. The researcher will specifically: evaluate effect of socio-cultural beliefs on Postpartum Family Planning uptake among postpartum mothers; assess perceived individual control of Postpartum Family Planning choice among postpartum; analyse fertility intentions for postpartum mothers after the intervention; compare Postpartum Family Planning uptake between control and intervention groups of postpartum and examine the determinants of Postpartum Family Planning uptake between control and intervention groups of postpartum mothers in Kisumu County.

Study design

This will be a prospective interventional study, a Randomised Control Trial (RCT) conducted in Kisumu County, Kisumu East sub County. The randomly sampled facilities are Migosi Health centre and Gita Health Centre for Intervention in urban and rural area respectively. The Community Units (CU) for community-based intervention will be Kuoyo CU and Nyalunya CU in in urban and rural area respectively. The control Facility and CUs will be Kowino HC and Chiga HC and their link CUs in urban and rural area respectively.

The study will have three arms. These will be facility intervention arm, community intervention arm and a control arm. The study will have three interacting phases. The pre-intervention phase, intervention phase and post-intervention phase. The proposed methods in each phase are not complex thus the overall design can be classified as simple intervention design.

Pre-intervention phase is for establishing sampling frame, intervention package and research tools formulation.

The aim of the intervention phase is to determine the effect of the targeted antenatal PPFP information package on the uptake of contraceptive methods during the postpartum period, in comparison with the standard of care. The intervention phase also integrates qualitative research that is aimed at identifying operational barriers and enablers of the intervention outcomes.

Randomization to control and intervention arms is at individual level within randomly selected control, community and the primary level health centres. Participants allocated to the experimental group will receive the targeted antenatal PPFP information package and those allocated to the control group will receive usual antenatal care.

The intervention will be; provision of antenatal information on PPFP using a standardized PPFP counselling tool and postpartum appointment setting. The control group will be under the routine standard antenatal care. There will be antenatal PPFP information provision training for the service providers at the facility and Community Health Assistants (CHA) for the community arm to standardize the intervention.

Study Population

This study will be among pregnant mothers in their second trimester, irrespective of age, attending ANC clinic in the intervention facilities or are within the respective CUs followed up to 3 months postpartum. The study will be conducted in 2 primary health centres and 1 community in the each of the two sub-counties. The Health centres eligibility depended on if: they offer the continuum of ANC, delivery, and PNC; they provide a selection of at least three modern contraceptive methods that are rated 2 or 1 on the Medical Eligibility Criteria (MEC) for postpartum contraceptives and there were no stock-outs of contraceptives during the preceding six months

Sampling Method

Multistage sampling will be applied involving purposive sampling for the sub counties, cluster sampling for the intervention and control facilities and community and simple random sampling for the subjects. One sub-county will be purposively sampled by the researcher; one with a rural and an urban set up and should be within easy reach by the team.

Cluster random sampling will then be used to get the 1 facility to be allocated to intervention arm and 1 to the control arm in each of the sub-county. The facilities will be matched based on (1) the average number of deliveries per month and (2) the operational level. Cluster random sampling will also be used to get the intervention CU. Each client meeting the criteria will then be randomly assigned to the study i.e. to the intervention and to the control arms using simple random sampling by picking folded paper labelled “yes” or “no”. There will be no blinding as the intervention facilities and controls are known.

Sample size determination

The sample size is estimated based on the following assumptions: among women at three months postpartum, KDHS data report 27% of use of any method (modern or traditional) in Kenya while the CPR in the general population is 53% (14). These figures allow the assumption of a desired 26% difference between control and the intervention groups (26% increase in adopting a modern contraceptive by three months postpartum). Therefore the sample size was calculated pairwise for two separate RCT for community arm and the control and the facility arm and the control (16–19). Rosner, 2015 proposed the sample size determination formula for difference in proportions with consideration of type I and II errors and power (18,20), Where q₁ = 1 − p₁, q₂ = 1 − p₂, , p1, p2 = proportion (incidence) of groups #1 (27%) and #2 (53%), Δ = |p2-p1| = absolute difference between two proportions (0.26), n1 = sample size for group #1, n2 = sample size for group #2, α = probability of type I error (is set at 0.05), β = probability of type II error (is set at 0.1 i.e. 90% power), z = critical Z value for a given α or β(1.96) and K = ratio of sample size for group #2 to group #1(1). Thus for practical equal sample distribution, the actual sample size shall be 246. Each facility shall have 41 clients

Data collection Procedure

Five tools will be used for data collection, namely; client exit interview guide, case report form, appointment card, Site appraisal form and questionnaire. All the tools will be used to collect quantitative data except site appraisal form and some questions in the questionnaire that need brief explanation. The theory of planned behaviour was applied to design quantitative process and outcome indicators and thus the tools (21). Client exit interview guide and Site appraisal form will be developed based on the procedures set out in the counselling guide. Appointment card will be source of information on client details, proposed date for PPFP initiation and vital PPFP information summary.

Data collection

Each health centre and community unit will have a trained research assistant. The assistant is to ensure adherence to the study manual and standard operating procedures for data management. The primary outcomes are; PPFP knowledge, the intent for use of PPFP (behavioural contracting) and the actual uptake of modern contraceptive methods at three months postpartum will largely be assessed based on the CRFs, appointment card and questionnaire. Actual uptake of modern contraceptive method will be established three months postpartum between the 12th to 14th weeks after birth. The CRFs will be filled on recruitment by the trained ANC service provider. The appointment card will be filled by the health worker after the client has accepted to set postnatal follow up date for PPFP. The questionnaire will be filled at 14 weeks postpartum during the scheduled MCH visit by a trained enumerator.

A process evaluation will be undertaken with the objectives of understanding the barriers and enablers related to the delivery of PPFP. This will be evaluated based on client exit interviews and site appraisal forms. The client exit interview guide and site visit appraisal form will be used to assess the process quality indicators which will include: waiting time, time/trimester of start of FP counselling, time after FP counselling, group/ individual session, availability of teaching aid on the table during counselling, gauging FP information level, application of GATHER (Greet, Ask, Tell, Help, Explain and Return/Refer) Model and BRAIDED (Benefits, Risks, Alternatives, Inquiries, Decision, Explanation, Documentation) Model. Satisfaction with information given, responses to questions, respectful care, confidentiality and privacy. Client exit interviews will be done by trained enumerator immediately after the intervention has been administered to reduce recall bias by the client. Site appraisal form will be filled on site visits by the research team and on the part of enumerator will be filled each day to include workload for ANC, number of staff available to offer ANC services, availability of FP counselling bag and flipchart.

Internal consistency will be ensured by piloting the tools and refining them to ensure they capture the essence of what they were meant to collect and Cronbach’s alpha of 0.7 will be acceptable.

Data management

The data will be password protected: only authorized users will be allowed access to the data. In addition, the collected information will be stored safely; hardcopies will be stored in lockable cabinets and soft copies will be secured by password. Data transmission will be encrypted to ensure data integrity and confidentiality of participants.

Analysis

Quantitative data entry will be done in IBM’s SPSS version 26. The sub-Country research teams will be responsible for verifying the data and a second verification will be done by the researcher to monitor data quality. Questions about data inconsistencies or missing values will be sent to sites and will be resolved on an ongoing basis. The participant will form the unit of analysis and intra-cluster correlation coefficient will be accounted for. All analysis will be by intention to treat Descriptive statistics will be performed by computing means, standard deviations, and minimum and maximum values for continuous variables, and frequencies and percentages for categorical variables. As part of quality control and descriptive analysis of the data, the distribution of variables to detect outliers will be examined. Descriptive statistics will be tabulated for individual clusters and aggregated across clusters.

On evaluating the effect of socio-cultural beliefs on Postpartum Family Planning uptake among postpartum mothers in Kisumu County, descriptive statistics on of prevalent sociocultural beliefs about PPFP will be summarized into frequencies and percentages. Bivariate analysis of effects of sociocultural beliefs on PPFP uptake will be done and presented on two-by-two (2×2) tables with Chi-square being the inferential statistics where P-value will determine the significance of homogeneity of proportions and odds ratio (OR) and 95% confidence interval (95% CI) will demonstrate the strength of the relationship. Binary logistic regression analysis will be done to adjust for confounders of sociocultural beliefs as determinants of PPFP uptake

Perceived individual control of Postpartum Family Planning choice among postpartum mothers in Kisumu County will be analysed using descriptive statistics aggregated based on sociodemographic aspects and presented in tables with means, median, range and standard deviation. This will further be analysed by student t-test to ascertain the significance in differences in means for the determinants of perceived control of family planning choice Significant determinants will be fitted in multilinear regression analysis to adjust for confounders

Fertility intentions for postpartum mothers will be disaggregated based on sociodemographic aspects and other individual characteristics. Intention to use PPFP will be simplified in proportions of the categorical yes or no to appointment for PPFP. Bivariate analysis of determinants of fertility intentions will be done and presented in two-by-two (2×2) tables with Chi-square being the inferential statistics. Binary logistic regression analysis will be done to adjust for confounders of determinants of fertility intentions.

Likewise, level of intention will be measure by Likert scale and analysed by t-test statistics after normality testing and adjusted for in linear regression analysis.

Postpartum Family Planning uptake between control and intervention groups of will be compared by use of simple clinical superiority in the proportions.

Bivariate analysis with chi-square statistics will be used to analyse the determinants of Postpartum Family Planning uptake between control and intervention groups and thus will form the selection criteria for inclusion in final regression model. Binary logistic regression analysis will be applied to adjust for confounders

Ethical considerations

The study has been approved by Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology (MMUST) School of Graduate Studies (SGS). Ethical clearance has been obtained from the MMUST Institutional Ethics Review Committee (IERC). An official data collection permission letter will be obtained from the county Director Health and Sanitation. A research authorization and permit has been acquired from NACOSTI. Signed written informed consent for participation will be obtained from all participants after they are introduced to the purpose of the study and informed about their rights. To ensure confidentiality and privacy, the names of the participants will not be recorded in the CRFs and data collection will be in privacy. Principle of justice and impartiality will be adhered to by enabling equal opportunity of the target population to participate in the study by use of probability sampling.

Trial status

This protocol version number 1 PACTR202109586388973 of the 28th September 2021. The researcher expects recruitment to begin approximately in November 15th 2021 and to be completed by February 2021.