Knowledge and experiences of community health workers in the delivery of physical rehabilitation services in Zambia- a qualitative interview study of trained community health workers

BACKGROUND

The World Health Organisation (WHO) describes community health workers (CHWs) as “lay care health workers selected from the community where they operate and are answerable to the very communities” that they serve [1]. In many low-income countries (LICs) like Zambia, CHWs have become the backbone of the community health system as they are an integral part of primary health care (PHC) and are essential for achieving universal health coverage (UHC) [2, 3], particularly in rural and poor communities. Community health programs have been extensively used to address the chronic shortage of human resources for health (HRH) through task shifting, which is an adaptive system that leads to improved access to health care and improved health outcomes [4, 5]. More specifically, CHWs have been involved in the delivery of physical rehabilitation services and have thus been involved in improving the quality of life of disabled people through task shifting various roles to them by trained physical rehabilitation workers like physiotherapists and occupational therapists [6, 7, 8]. In settings where such programs have been implemented, CHWs deliver physical rehabilitation services to the community as rehabilitation health workers or rehabilitation assistants [9, 10].

It is estimated that there are fewer than ten skilled rehabilitation workers per one million people in LICs, and this results in population’s limited access to rehabilitation services. The shortage of HRH therefore has an adverse effect on communities in LICs amid a high burden of chronic and communicable diseases that can lead to physical impairments [11, 12, 13]. In countries where CHWs have been used to deliver physical rehabilitation services, they have adopted various roles such as case managers, providers of basic assistive devices and issuing assistive devices [14, 15, 16]. Physical rehabilitation task shifting has also resulted in the training regimen of CHWs ranging from two-day sessions to a two-year training program that covers various physical rehabilitation components like health promotion, exercise prescription, and palliative care [14, 17].

Zambia’s National Health Care is responsible for physical rehabilitation services that are provided at three levels [18]. With a population of 19 million, Zambia is plagued by a HRH crisis hence the need for an increased ratio of HRH to general population [19, 20]. While Zambia’s healthcare system is decentralized, the majority of appropriately qualified physical rehabilitation workers are found in urban areas and in settings that are accessible by railway. The majority of these HRH are located in three main areas, namely Lusaka, the Copper Belt, and Southern provinces [18, 21]. Due to a dire shortage of physical rehabilitation workers, primary health care level is particularly affected, hence non-governmental organizations (NGO) supplement physical rehabilitation services at community level by engaging a few physical rehabilitation workers and CHWs. Therefore, these services provided are mainly aligned with the relevant NGO’s objectives, such as treating children with cerebral palsy and ensuring that the disabled are provided with orthotics or prosthetics [22].

Task shifting physical rehabilitation services to CHWs at the primary health care level improves accessibility, especially for the disabled and the vulnerable [23]. However, while the physical rehabilitation services that are delivered by CHWs need to be safe, efficient, effective, equitable, and sustainable, there is no standardised approach to the training of the CHWs who are tasked with physical rehabilitation services [24]. Therefore, understanding CHWs’ knowledge and experiences regarding physical rehabilitation service delivery is essential. The purpose of this paper was to investigate the knowledge and experiences of CHWs trained in physical rehabilitation and thereby deliver physical rehabilitation services in the selected study area in Zambia.

METHODS

RESULTS

Ten interviews were conducted with purposively selected CHWs. All the participants had been trained in physical rehabilitation service delivery under ZECREP. The CHWs’ ages ranged from 34 to 56 years. The highest education level attained by the participants was Grade 12, while the lowest qualification was Grade 7. The CHWs’ years of experience in general community health were between 5 to 15 years, and all the participants had been delivering physical rehabilitation services for a minimum of 16 months before the interviews (Table 1).

DISCUSSION

This show that with training CHWs’ had gained adequate knowledge to diagnose the severity of disabled children’s condition and to prescribe some treatment procedures to support them, but this knowledge was clearly not enough in more severe cases as such children would be referred to more appropriately trained professionals. They had relatively similar experiences regarding the physical rehabilitation services they provided, such as the creation of simple assistive devices and educating the entire family to support the disabled child in the household. The literature affirms that the performance and skills of CHWs that render physical rehabilitation services are essential for the benefit of the patient, the caregiver, and themselves [27]. Moreover, research has shown that trained CHWs who engage in rehabilitation programmes can retain knowledge and improve their service delivery significantly [28]. As a sustainable solution to the shortage of physical rehabilitation workers, the knowledge and experiences of CHWs are important in the community health care field [29].

The participants highlighted that they were knowledgeable of patient management, planning treatment programs, issuing simple assistive devices, and in diagnosing and referring patients who require more sophisticated treatment regimens. The CHWs had adequate knowledge to take a patient’s history. They did this by obtaining information from the child’s caregiver/s and they conducted problem assessment by examining the child’s abilities and inabilities. In history taking, obtaining information from caregivers is a crucial part of the assessment process as it contributes to making the correct decision about the child patient’s needs [30]. Additionally, the CHWs could design and focus on treatment regimens for the children in their care and they could devise treatment plans that incorporated activities that would enhance the life of their patients and improve the involvement of the family and caregivers. Generally, the CHWs operated on guidelines used by qualified providers who assess children subjectively before an objective physical examination to ascertain the child’s problems and determine the most appropriate rehabilitation procedure [31].

The CHWs’ mode of delivery was home-based, which is an effective rehabilitation approach in improving the functioning of disabled children [32], especially with cerebral palsy children. While the CHWs scheduled a specific day of the week per child for treatment amidst other healthcare duties, literature shows that increasing treatment intensity results in better outcomes for children as treatment frequency should be established not on the principles of rehabilitation and child development, but rather on clinical reasoning and scheduling [33, 34]. Meanwhile, the CHWs offered health education to the family to equip them all with knowledge and insight about the cerebral palsy child’s condition [35]. This approach was for families to enhance their knowledge and skills, and fostered household education in the care of disabled children.

The fact that the CHWs made and issued home-made assistive devices to the disabled children in their care is in line with Articles 4, 20, and 26 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which requires countries to make devices available to the disabled at low cost [36]. Weak health systems in low-income countries such as Zambia pose a dire challenge regarding assistive device availability due to resource constraints and a lack of trained personnel which, in turn, leads to low domestic production and availability of assistive devices. The onus in such countries thus falls on CHWs to provide low-cost aids to assist the population, particularly children, who need support [37, 38].

The CHWs were knowledgeable of the primary health care system and how to refer patients to other health professionals who were members of the multidisciplinary health care team. While the CHWs’ mode of operation was home-based, they were supervised by a trained physiotherapist who was based at the zonal health centre. This centre was reportedly primarily responsible for health promotion and disease prevention and some limited curative services, while complicated cases were referred to the Level 1 hospital [18]. This means that, whenever cases required further management, the CHWs made referrals and did not need to work in isolation. The literature affirms that a functioning process of referrals ensures the continuation of case management which is a vital process for quality health service delivery [39].

However, the CHWs experienced anxiety when they were required to make a physical examination and clinical diagnoses using information provided by the children’s caregivers to arrive at an appropriate diagnosis. As members of the communities they served, the CHWs strove to provide appropriate treatment regimens that would be culturally acceptable and beneficial to their young patients. The World Health Organisation endorses this approach in a systematic review which states that CHWs should provide culturally acceptable services while improving service access for communities [40]. The clinical diagnoses the CHWs made were thus dependent on their competence which had been instilled during the training they had received. This suggests that any training CHWs receive should be of an appropriate standard to guide them to assess a patient and arrive at a correct diagnosis [41].

The data concerning physical rehabilitation service delivery by CHWs revealed that their experiences were diverse. For instance, some of these experiences related to patient care while others included patient/caregiver expectations and a lack of resources. A common feature was that all the CHWs conducted home-based care programs and family education, which means that their services were embedded in families at community level and that family education was core to their practice. This was a heartening finding as the involvement of family members in health interventions, particularly where disabled children are concerned, is associated with a positive influence on family health practices, and thus knowledge at household level of the management of a disabled child is recommended [42].

In their efforts to assist the children in need of special care, the CHWs made simple tools that could be used as assistive devices by the children. However, they admitted that they had to access more sophisticated devices via relevant health authorities. Their dedication thus meant that the use of simple assistive devices by their young patients was assured, while external support for more complicated ones was accessible. The goal of the WHO Community-Based Rehabilitation Guidelines on Assistive Devices is that disabled people should have access to suitable devices to help them participate in everyday life [43]. The role of health systems is therefore to determine which assistive devices are needed by which disabled persons, and to facilitate access to such devices. Furthermore, health systems are mandated to ensure the maintenance, repair, and replacement of such devices when necessary [43]. However, as the access to assistive devices in LICs like Zambia are limited, homemade assistive devices have been a solution to help with children’s progress in physical rehabilitation [37].

The CHWs also had positive experiences of the referral process as they reported prompt attention to the children who needed more advanced care. This is commendable as it speaks to the fact at primary health care, child health is a health priority in Zambia [18]. Apart from the fact that preferential health treatment is an enabler of a good referral system, the proper organisation of health services enables service providers to work as a team, and this team spirit facilitates effective referrals from one point to the other [44].

On a less positive note, the CHWs were exposed to unrealistic expectations from the caregivers of the children they served. For instance, there was the high and unrealistic expectation that physical rehabilitation would heal the child, and quickly. In health service delivery, such unrealistic expectations among caregivers may be attributed to anxiety and insufficient information [45], and this underscores the need for family health education programmes. Additionally, due to the community’s lack of understanding of the role of the CHWs, they expected to receive financial benefits from them. This is unfortunate and may be attributed to the fact that some NGO-driven programs actually provide material benefits for families.

The CHWs were also constrained by a lack of resources which negatively impacted the physical rehabilitation services they were able to deliver. For instance, the lack of schools for special needs children and inappropriate infrastructure for disabled children in existing schools limited the outcomes of their work as their clients could not progress optimally. Zambia, like many other developing countries, is challenged by a lack of special education facilities and infrastructure for the disabled as a result of poor political will, cultural influences, and limited resources that are all compounded by poverty [46]. Moreover, the fact that these CHWs were volunteers who were not remunerated meant that they lacked the necessary resources to support their own families. The literature also notes that a lack of permanent employment opportunities for CHWs is a barrier in various CHW programmes, particularly as most programs in sub-Saharan Africa are donor funded and mostly for vertical disease programs [47]. Integrating CHWs, like those who participated in the study, into the national health care system like any other salaried health worker will therefore guarantee permanent employment and the sustainability of their contribution to health care services, especially for disabled children.

CONCLUSION

The knowledge of the CHWs regarding the physical rehabilitation of disabled children was enhanced through training as they were able to understand basic patient management, plan treatment programs, create and issue appropriate assistive devices, and work in multidisciplinary teams. However, their experiences regarding patient care, patient expectations, and the availability of resources were somewhat diverse, while they all agreed that their experiences of patient referrals were positive. The knowledge base and experiences that are highlighted in this paper may guide the development of a more suitable training model for CHWs that will enhance their knowledge, skills, and development and that will ensure their professional integration into the health care system in Zambia. In consideration of the shortage of committed and properly trained HRH in low-income countries, it seems vital that CHWS are adequately trained in physical rehabilitation service delivery on a national scale to curb existing shortages.

Affiliation

University of KwaZulu-Natal, School of Nursing and Public Health, Department of Public Health Medicine, 2^nd Floor George Campbell Building, Durban 4001, Republic of South Africa

Contributors

MM conceptualised and wrote the manuscript. TD supervised and contributed to the writing of the manuscript.

Funding

None

Competing interests

None

Patient consent for publication

Not applicable.

Ethical approval

This study was cleared by the University of KwaZulu-Natal Biomedical Research Ethics Committee (BREC 00000569/2019), and permission to conduct the study was obtained from the Zambia National Health Research Authority.

Miriam Mapulanga ORCID ID - http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5519-6635

Participants’ consent for publication

Participants had the right to opt out of the study without any repercussions. Confidentiality was maintained throughout the study by using codes instead of real names for study participants and data were not made available to any other partner or project for further analysis. A consent form was signed by the participants before the interview in which they agreed that the data they provided could be used anonymously for research and publication purposes.

Data availability statement

No data available