Occupational hazards and risks among the women in fisher communities in Cox’s Bazar and Chattogram

Background

Globally, fisheries and aquaculture sector produce more than two hundred million tonnes of fish, aquatic animals and algae critically contributing to global food security and nutrition. ¹ This industry employs over 58.5 million people worldwide, with women making up 21% of those workers. ² In Bangladesh, around 17 million people depend on fishing, fish farming, fish handling, and fish processing for their sustenance.³ Marine fishery is vital component in Bangladesh’s fishing industry because of the country’s extensive coastline and marine zone.

Around 30% of the women in rural and coastal areas of Bangladesh are engaged in fisheries sector.⁴ Women in fisher communities in Bangladesh have a twofold dilemma since patriarchal societal norms limit their activities to the home, but rising poverty and landlessness also force them to look for wage work. Thereby, they are to play both role, fishing activities as well as traditional household chores. An earlier baseline study in Cox’s Bazar and Chattogram revealed that women in the fisher communities were engaged in a wide range of fisheries activities including fish sorting, grading, cutting, dry fish processing, dry fish paste (Nappi) processing, daily laboring in fish farms, transporting, selling fish or fish products, net making, ice processing, fish basket making, and collecting minnow and seashells from the sea shores.⁵ Still, traditionally, fishing and related activities in Bangladesh are considered to be the occupation of men in Bangladesh, particularly in coastal regions, and women’s contributions to this sector are grossly neglected.

Globally, people engaged in fishery sector encounter numerous occupational hazards, including the risk of boat capsizing, slippery surface, unsafe handling of heavy weight, fish bites and stings, snake and insect bites and exposure to physical hazards, like sun, salt water and noise, which may result in various illness and deteriorated heath conditions, including injuries, fatalities, skin, respiratory and auditory diseases.^6–8, According to the World Health Organisation (WHO) and the International Labour Organisation (ILO), globally, almost 2 million individuals died as a result of occupational hazards in 2016.⁹

The Committee on Fisheries (COFI) declaration for sustainable fisheries and acuaculture emphasized to enhance women’s full access to and equal opportunities in the fisheries sector.¹⁰ To achieve this, occupational safety and health of the women engaged in the fisheries should be a key consideration. There are several studies available both at country and global level on the occupational hazards encountered by the men in the fisheries sector. However, only a few studies^11–12 available that identified occupational hazards and risk factors of women engaged in fishery activities. In Bangladesh, there is no study available on the occupational hazards of women working in fisheries, except, a qualitative study¹³ found that women engaged in fishing with their children possesses the risk of drowning since the traditional cloths are not flexible enough for free-movement in the water.

Fishery is one of the oldest and most prevalent occupations in Cox’s bazar and Chattogram coastal communities. Fishery engages a wide range of occupational activities, including production, harvesting, processing, handling, storage and transportation. Traditionally, men and women have different roles, while men are mostly engaged in harvesting, women are mostly engaged in fish processing. Therefore, women may experience distinctive hazards and risks in their occupation, which is vital to reveal to ensure a safe work environment for them. Moreover, it is also essential to understand the measures in place to prevent occupational hazards and risks, such as personal safety training and personal protection equipment, for proper planning of preventive strategies. The study was conducted to identify the different occupational hazards that women in fisher communities in Chattogram and Cox’s Bazar were exposed to, the occupational risks that ensued from those hazards, and the extent of health and safety measures that were in place to prevent occupational health hazards.

Methodology

Results

Discussion

This study gives in-depth insights into the occupational hazards and health risks experienced by the women actively engaged in the fisheries sector in Cox’s Bazar and Chattogram. To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first study carried among the fisherwomen in Bangladesh revealing their occupational health hazards and risks. The study found a high occurrence of occupational hazards, health risks and disease conditions and limited availability of preventive measures among the women in the fisher communities in coastal areas of Bangladesh.

The demographic profile of our study participants reflects the distinctive characteristics of women working in the fisheries sector in Cox’s Bazar and Chattogram. We have found an alarming status of education among the women in fisheries sector, with most participants unable to sign or could merely sign, indicating high rate of illiteracy among the women in fisher communities. Literacy rate is comparatively very low among the fishermen in Bangladesh ^18–19 and due to gender-based discrimination the rate is further low among women in the fisherfolk communities⁵. Such a lack of education may have an impact on their awareness of work hazards as well as their capacity to acquire and comprehend safety information and procedures. Therefore, awareness raising, and prevention strategies related to occupational hazards should be customized based on the education status of the women.

Our study revealed that women were engaged in mainly three types of fisheries industries - dry fish processing, raw fish processing and marketing and dry fish paste (nappi) processing, with majority of them (88.41%) dedicating direct manual labour. Traditionally, women in the coastal regions of Bangladesh are not engaged in fish harvesting, which is usually seen as occupation of man. This aligns with the social norms of majority of the world’s small scale fishing communities, where men are the primary producers and women get engaged in fish processing, marketing and distribution.²⁰ Interestingly, a significant majority of women were involved in different fishing operations at the same time, demonstrating the variety and adaptability of their positions in this sector. Common daily chores were fish sorting and grading, fish cutting or scale removal, and minnow collection illustrating the multifarious nature of their employment. Women in the fisher communities also need to get engaged in household chores and caregiving to their children.⁵ Such double burden of household responsibilities and economic workload may have significant effect on their health.²¹

The study found a number of physical safety hazards that causes injuries to the women. Slippery surface in the workplace is a commonly reported hazard for women, which may not only cause acute injuries but also chronic musculoskeletal disorders. This finding is consistent with findings of other studies in Kenya¹¹ and India¹², which also reported accidental falls and injuries happening among fisher women due to the slippery surface. Our study found the high occurrence of injuries among the women working in fisheries sector, which include sharp cut injuries, laceration, fracture, bruise, blunt trauma and amputation. Injuries among fisherwomen were also evidenced in previous studies among fisherfolks of coastal states in India²², Irular tribal community¹² and Fisherfolk in Kampi Samaki¹¹. Although most of the injuries are minor and nonfatal, unable to properly treat the wound in a timely way may result in infection.²³ In Cox’s Bazar and Chattogram coastal areas, as revealed by our study, the injuries can result from a range of workplace physical safety hazards such as fishing or minnow collecting instruments (e.g. nets), fish cutting instruments and fish stings or bites. Women engaged in dry fish processing need to cut or descale the fishes using sharp instruments, accidental handling of such instruments may result in the sharp cut injuries, laceration and even amputation of fingers.

Many of the women engage themselves in minnow collection at the seashores, specially, during monsoon season, using small fishing nets and bamboo poles. Some women reported cuts and trauma from such nets and poles. Although less common, a few women performing this activity also reported the risk of drifting away to sea while working near the coast. This finding could be consistent with the finding of Dutta¹³, who claimed women in Bangladesh engaged in fishing with their children possesses the risk of drowning since the traditional cloths are not flexible enough for free movement in the water. A few have reported injuries to their hands, legs, and feet from sharp stones, corals, or oysters submerged in water, particularly when working submerged in sea water for collecting minnow or prawns. This hazard for cut injury was also reported by Velvizhi and Gopalakrishnan¹², who argued that wounds resulting from oyster shells could generally be very deep, bleed profusely and get infected.

More than half of the women identified fish sting or fish bite as an agent for their injuries. Most of the women working in the fisheries sector are to directly handle the fishes for sorting, grading, cutting, descaling or drying. Those who engaged in dry fish processing also need to make special knots near around gum of some fish species. Since they handle the fishes without any personal protection equipment (e.g. gloves), they commonly encounter the injuries from the fish spines or teeth. Often, such injury leaves with short- and long-term pores on hands and feet of the women. Such injuries caused by fish species is common among men and women working in the fishery sector and reported by large number of studies in Nigeria⁸, Kenya¹¹ and India¹². Fish stings and bites may also result in infections and subsequent amputation of fingers or toes.²⁴

The study found high prevalence of musculoskeletal disease conditions among the women in fishery sector as reported by more than two-third of the interviewed women. This includes, generalized body ache, back pain, neck pain, joint pain and stiffness, reduced range of movement, muscle weakness, numbness of limbs and physical deformity. This is consistent with a study among fisherwomen in India, which found that 67% of the fisherwomen complaining of musculoskeletal pain and discomfort, especially for lower back, knee and upper back²². In our setting, this finding could be related to a wide range of ergonomic hazards identified by this study, such as working in uncomfortable body posture, prolonged sitting in an uncomfortable position and carrying heavy weight. One of the unique findings of this study is that we found women are to sit on their feet without any support to hip or back during their fish processing and minnow collecting activities. Such uncomfortable and unsupported body posture may result in different musculoskeletal conditions, including low back pain, cervical pain and joint pain. Women engaged in the fishery sector also need to manually carry heavy weight, such as fish and dry fish, during their fish processing activity. Heavy weight carrying as a factor for musculoskeletal disease conditions among fisherwomen was also reported in previous studies¹¹. Many of the women also need walk long distance for collecting and delivery of fish and fish products in our setting, which also may lead to musculoskeletal pain. This is consistent with the finding of the study among the Irular fisherwomen.¹²

Although, use of pesticide in dry fish industry is strictly prohibited by the law in Bangladesh, some women informed that they get exposed to pesticides in their dry fish farm. Occupational exposure of pesticide can be associated with respiratory health problems, including asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and lung cancer. ²⁵ Establishing an association between exposures of the fisherwomen to pesticide and developing different clinical conditions was beyond the scope of this research, since it requires clinical diagnosis of the cases. However, our study found a high rate of occurrence of self-reported respiratory complaints, especially chronic cough, respiratory distress and chronic respiratory discomfort/breathlessness among the fisherwomen. Further research is warranted to explore the association between chemical exposure and respiratory diseases.

Our study found that majority of the women get frequent contact with salt water (90%) and salt (81%) in their daily activities, and more than half of the women reported that they develop some kind of physical symptoms, such as eye irritation, skin irritation, ear itching and earache, in reaction to the salt water. We have also noted a high incidence of skin diseases among the women in fisher communities, including skin allergy, irritation, ulceration and wounds. Salt or salt water could be the potential factor for such incidents as a recent study²⁶ found that sodium chloride could be a potential factor in the progression of allergy in the skin. This could also be related to contact with certain fish species that provoke allergic reactions.²⁷ Velvizhi and Gopalakrishnan¹² argued that exposure to brackish water, jellyfish and algal bloom can result in skin irritation, rashes and psoriasis among fisherwomen. However, further research is warranted to statistically establish the assumption.

The study found that nearly all (99%) of the women got exposed to direct sunlight for more than 4 hours a day and majority of them reported some kind of reaction or sensitivity to sun exposure, which included headache, skin irritation, sun burn and eye irritation. Ultraviolet radiation of sunray may result in acute sunburn and chronic skin changes, including skin cancer.²⁸ Sunburn among fisherwomen was also reported as a health concern in Kenya.¹¹ Kyei et al.²⁹ identified seawater and sunrays as ocular hazards causing ocular irritation, tearing, red eyes and blurred vision. We also found high incidence of eye related diseases or symptoms among the women in fisherfolk, which include eye irritation, ocular pain, red eye and reduced vision. These could be related to the prolonged exposure to sun and/or saltwater.

Fisher folks in Chattogram and Cox’s Bazar live in overcrowded settings with fragile shelter and compromised water, sanitation and hygienic practices. Our study found that more than three-fourth of the women in the fisherfolk did not have the provision of sanitary latrine and handwashing with soap at their workplaces. All these factors can contribute to a high burden of communicable diseases among the fisherfolk community. This could be evidenced by the fact, as found in our study, of a very high incidence of self-reported communicable diseases, specially, diarrhea, dysentery, flue/viral fever, respiratory infection, tuberculosis, skin infections and helminthiasis among the women in fisher communities. Moreover, we also found that nearly three-fourth of the women needed to remain wearing wet clothes for prolonged time. Weather in Bangladesh is hot and humid, especially during the summer. Both these factors – wet clothing and warm weather are risk factors for tinea³⁰. Concurring this, in our study we found that half of the women had self-reported incidence of tinea in last 12 months. Although, the reported incidents communicable diseases were not clinically verified, intensified health promotion and risk communication efforts are recommended both at community level and at workplace to improve the hygienic behavior and practices.

Many of the hazards could be mitigated by use of personal protective equipment, such as gloves, masks, sunglasses, sunscreen and gumboots.¹⁴ However, we have found majority of the women in the fisher communities did not use any personal protection equipment at their workplace. While use of gloves could prevent many of the injuries associated with fish bite or sting and sharp instruments, commonly available heavy-duty gloves may not be feasible for fisherwomen since these are not suitable to use for fine work carried out by the women during fish processing. Therefore, personal protection equipment should be innovated or customized considering the local need, context and requirement. Moreover, the fisherwomen should be trained and mobilized for using personal protection equipment for their health and safety. Finally, we have found that the first aid kits were grossly unavailable at the workplace, with which injuries could be managed early and risk of wound infection could be prevented. Strong advocacy is needed to influence the fish industry players to make personal protection equipment and first aid kits available at the workplace.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Women in the fisher communities in Bangladesh are engaged in a wide range of activities in the fisheries sector. Our study found a high occurrence of occupational hazards experienced by the women, including physical safety, physical, chemical, ergonomic and biologic hazards. Due to unavailability of adequate preventive and safety measures, the hazards are resulting in a wide range of health risks and disease conditions among the women in the fisher communities, including injuries, musculoskeletal disorders, skin diseases, eye diseases, respiratory diseases and communicable diseases. However, their workplaces are pervasively missing with the availability of personal protection equipment, first aid kits and health and safety benefits. Notwithstanding the adversities, the women continue to work hard in the fishing industry, even though their efforts are merely acknowledged in the society. Therefore, a comprehensive multisectoral strategy, considering the below recommendations, needs to be undertaken to mitigate the occupational hazards and prevent associated diseases among the women in fisher communities promoting their health and wellbeing.

1. The women working in the fisheries sector should be trained on the occupational hazards and risks, and safety and preventive measures.

2. Procedure should be innovated or identified in consultation with fisheries sector experts regarding safe handling of fish and associated instruments to prevent injuries from physical safety hazards.

3. First aid kits should be made available at all workplaces and a focal person from the workers should be trained in the use of the kits.

4. Engineering and ergonomic innovations are necessary to prevent ergonomic hazards. This could include proper sitting arrangement, measures to avoid prolonged standing and convenient tools (e.g. carts, wheel barrows) to carry heavy weight.

5. Personal protection equipment should be made available to the women in the fisher folk and train and motivate them on their use. The PPE should be customized for use in the fisheries sector context.

6. Advocacy should be conducted to orient the fish industry owners on the occupational hazards, so that they improve the workplace safety and ergonomics and arrange measures to prevent physical hazards, including direct sun exposure and noise, and ensure use and supply of personal protection equipment.

7. Hygienic conditions should be improved at both workplace and personal level, including arrangement of sanitary latrines, soap and water for handwashing, safe drinking water and promotion of personal hygiene.

8. Restrict use of insecticide in dry fish processing and promote organic method of dry fish processing to prevent exposure to chemical hazards.

9. Establish a mechanism for regular health checkup of the women engaged in the fisheries sector to prevent disease or illness at early stage.

10. Advocacy should be conducted with the owner of the fisher industries to ensure maternal benefits, menstrual hygiene mechanisms at workplace.

Supporting information

S1. Dataset of the study. Dataset of the study is attached as reference.