“Go and bring your husband”: a COM-B guided qualitative study on the barriers to male involvement in antenatal care in Bamenda Health District, Cameroon

Study design

We chose a qualitative study design underpinned by the naturalistic enquiry approach to explore perspectives on the barriers to male ANC attendance(35). This was suitable as it enabled us to use semi-structured interviews (SSIs) and Focus Group Descriptions (FGDs) to capture participant accounts and provide comprehensive summaries of the factors that impede male participation in antenatal care.

Study setting

Our study was conducted in Bamenda Health District in the North West Region of Cameroon. The North-West region is a historically disadvantaged, politically unstable and high-density region—currently ranked 3^rd most populous in Cameroon with an estimated population of 2 million inhabitants(36). The region has one of the poorest reproductive, maternal and child health indices in the country. Antenatal care coverage of at least one visit was 58% in 2017; childhood immunization coverage was 68% and under five mortality was 57 per 1000 live births(26,37) In 2018, the adult HIV prevalence in the region was estimated at 4.0%, which is higher than the national average while maternal HIV prevalence was estimated at 5.0%(38). The region is largely traditional and patriarchal with prohibitive gender norms and socio-cultural customs that impede male involvement in maternal and child health services(27).

Bamenda Health District is the largest of the 19 districts in the North West Region. The district is located in an urban and peri-urban locality composed of 17 health areas and 35 health facilities—18 public, 12 lay private and 5 confessional serving an estimated population of 800,000 urban and rural residents(36). The main public facility is Bamenda Regional Hospital – a level 2 referral hospital. The district covers a total surface area of 560km² and is centrally located within the city of Bamenda —which serves both as the administrative headquarters of Mezam Division and capital city of the North West Region of Cameroon. The city is cosmopolitan with inhabitants originating across the national territory and neighbouring Nigeria. It is made up of three towns: Mankon, Nkwen and Bamendankwe represented by Bamenda I, II, and III Sub-divisions respectively(36).

Study participants for this study were drawn from Nkwen Baptist Health Centre within Cameroon Baptist Convention Health Services (CBCHS) —a private faith-based NGO in Cameroon. The facility has a modern infrastructure with a 114 bed capacity and 250 staff attending to over 18000 patients monthly(39). It was purposively chosen because it is centrally located within Nkwen town in Bamenda II Sub-division, and has high volume antenatal clinics (over 358 clients per month) with well-established Option B+ services. It also attracts a mix of clients with varying socio-cultural backgrounds that was important for this study

Participant recruitment and sampling approach

Pregnant or recently postpartum women, male partners and ANC/HIV health workers who were 18 years and above were eligible for inclusion in this study. We employed purposive maximum variation sampling in order to achieve maximal variation regarding age, parity and couple ANC attendance. The variation in our selection was underpinned by the need to capture a wide range of perspectives, perceptions and experiences in order to identify and report common patterns that emerge from heterogeneity(40). We therefore observed group antenatal and post-natal consultations to subjectively identify information-rich participants whom we subsequently approached and invited for interviews or group discussions(41).

We followed recommendations for sample size estimation based on the study question, established evidence on sample size estimates for similar studies and informational redundancy as per the +3 criterion(42,43). A total of 103 eligible women and their male partners were therefore approached of whom 90 consented; four women declined and nine men who were contacted through telephone were unreachable. Of the 80 pregnant women and male partners who accepted our invitation, 44 were women (n= 38 SSIs; n=6, FGDs) and 36 were men (n= 30 SSIs; n=6, FGDs). We purposefully recruited 10 Staff members (two male and eight female) for an FGD based on their clinical roles within ANC/HIV units and their level of education.

To ascertain that saturation was being achieved, we adopted a hybrid approach—data set and individual interviews by discussing the depth and breadth of participant views and perspectives during debriefing sessions, reviewed fieldnotes for recurrent and divergent themes, and noted where infrequent or no new views were expressed(44). Additionally, we probed participant views during interviews until no new information about a particular topic was forthcoming.

Data collection

The data collection process began with site visits for institutional approval, ANC observation, participant recruitment between January and June 2021. This was closely followed by interviews and FGDs interspaced with debriefing sessions between July and December 2021.

The corresponding author (LHF)— conducted the majority of SSIs (53) and co-facilitated all FGDs. LHF was assisted by a female Bachelor’s degree nurse midwife and a female master’s level sociologist who served as co-interviewers, observers and note-takers during group discussions. The study’s languages were Pidgin (Cameroonian Creole) and English depending on participant preference. We took field notes during interviews and FDGs to capture non-verbal cues and unanticipated events. Although these notes served as an additional source of data, they were not used as primary data sources during analysis. They provided context to participant responses, aid debriefing and enrich analytic memos.

SSIs and group FGDs were conducted using topic guides. The development of these guides was theoretically underpinned by empirical evidence, the National MCH handbook and the COM-B model mapped unto the TDF. Participants were broadly asked: What are the barriers that prevent men from attending ANC? Why do you perceive them as barriers? How do you feel about these barriers? We used these guides iteratively with additional prompts beginning with participants’ responses to enrich and add depth to concepts that emerged during interviews and group discussions

With the exception of the staff FGD guide, topic guides and demographic forms were piloted with two postpartum women and one pregnant woman. These were further refined following feedback from participants and the research team. With the exception of two SSIs, all SSIs and FGDs were conducted face-to-face in a private room at the health facility. With permission from participants, interviews and FDGs were audio-recorded, translated and transcribed verbatim. Interviews sessions lasted between 22 – 65 minutes while FGDs lasted between 1-2hrs. Participants were provided snacks and transport reimbursements which ranged between 350frs CFA (40pence) and £1 (750frs CFA).

Data management and analysis

Both FGDs and SSIs transcripts were anonymized with numbers and combined to represent one data set and managed using NVIVO(45). The first five transcripts were checked against audio for accuracy following the agreed SOP that was developed for this study. The overall approach to analysis was directed content analysis followed by inductive thematic analysis(46,47). Summarily, analysis broadly involved a 7-stage approach with combined guidelines adapted from both Hsieh and Braun as outlined in the supplemental file 1 &2 (46,47). The relevance of themes for inclusion was informed by three criteria: (1) frequency of occurrence, (2) presence of conflicting beliefs (3) perceived strength of the belief to influence the target behaviour(48,49). This was finalized with a tabular representation of themes matched to, belief statements, COM-B constructs and relevant theoretical domains. This matrix (See supplementary file 3) was reviewed by TN and HS for further insight, refinement, interpretation and exploration of dissonant areas.

Ethical consideration

Ethical approval for this study was granted by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine ethics committee (Ref: 18003) and the Cameroon Baptist Convention Health Services Internal Review Board (IRB2019-33). Written informed consent was sought from all participants. Participants were assured of confidentiality, anonymity and the non-impact of their participation on the care they were receiving.

Limited awareness on the need for men in antenatal attendance

The majority of participants reported that the low involvement of men in ANC is as a result of the limited awareness and knowledge about their role in MCH and specifically ANC attendance which is generally perceived as a woman’s duty.“I think the very first thing is that men fail to know that they have a part to play during antenatal attendance because they think it is the woman’s duty to come, learn and practice what she has been told”— Male FGD participant, in their 20s. “He is not really informed about the importance of couple ANC visit as a parent or partner should” —Female SSI participant, in their 30s.

A subset of study participants who echoed this perspective blamed this lack of awareness on the health system that has not made provision for men by requiring and duly informing them for ANC attendance with their pregnant partners.I blame the ignorance on the part of the health authorities. They have not made a provision for us. If a pregnant woman does not go for antenatal care, even an uneducated grandmother will ask her why because they know it is mandated. However, when a man does not go, nobody will ask him questions because it is not mandated anywhere. I believe that these health institutions should be the ones to make it mandatory and permit men to have their own clinic day or come along with their wives.— Male FGD participant, in their 30s.

Limited female agency to initiate male involvement

Based on anecdotal evidence, health providers verbally require pregnant women to bring their partners for ANC attendance. Most of our female participants reported that they do not have the agency to bear the initial responsibility of convincing and involving their male partners for participation in ANC activities. Both men and women in our study therefore expressed the preference for the health system to bear the initial invitation for male involvement—not women who think their partners will not believe them and not a self-initiative from men themselves who don’t wish to intrude because of long-held perceptions that antenatal clinics are spaces reserved for women.“Sometimes I when I tell him that they said men should come for ANC, he thinks I am joking and only want him to be moving around with me. When he sees an invitation from the hospital he would know that it is a serious issue. Otherwise, it will sound like I am the one forcing him to come.”— Female SSI participant, in their 20s.

Maternal extortion

Most respondents opined that men generally bear the financial responsibility for prenatal care in Cameroon and some pregnant women prevented their partners from participating in ANC attendance because they preferred to conceal the true cost of accessing ANC services. They did so in the hope of receiving more money than is actually needed. As such, respondents therefore classified these group of women as part of the barriers to male ANC attendance as they fear the presence of male partners could expose their extortionary schemes.“Women are also barriers. They don’t want their partners to come as participant number 5 mentioned because they don’t want the men to know the amount they are spending for ANC. They use pregnancy as a forum to exhort a lot of money from their partners.” — Staff FGD participant, in their 40s. Some women don’t also give the opportunity for their husbands to come with them for financial reasons. They don’t want them to know what is happening here and how much is being spent. — Female SSI participant, in their 30s.

Restrictive gender, social & cultural norms on male ANC attendance

Apart from the fact that men feel out of place in antenatal clinics, restrictive gender, social and cultural norms on masculinity inhibited the effective participation of men in antenatal care. Gender normative assumptions that men are superior to women and should opt-out of antenatal care in order to maintain their bread-winning role and dominance were some of the factors participants stated for the low participation of men in ANC. Sub-themes that emerged under this are substantiated below with illustrative quotes.

Male partner sense of superiority about attending ANC

During interviews and group discussions, it was noted that the Cameroonian society is largely patriarchal. Study participants reported that men hold positions of dominance and are considered superior to women to the extent that attending ANC together with other women is a tacit admission that they are in equal standing with women. Respondents therefore intimated that this perception on the superiority of men prevented most men from attending ANC together with their partners. They also noted that some men who eventually made it to ANC clinics decided to sit at the periphery to observe from a non-identifiable distance.

“I think there is a cultural [gender] attachment to this. You know, we African men we have a certain way of relating with women—it is a kind of boss-subordinate relationship. I am the head of the family. I have to dictate and the woman follows…Men don’t see themselves and women as being equals. So they don’t feel comfortable sitting and being given health education together with women. A man may feel like, ‘if I go to clinic with my wife, it may appear like my wife and I are equal’” — Male SSI participant, in their 30s.

Lack of male social identity in antenatal clinics

Participants reported that men perceive ANC as a woman’s affair because it is largely attended by women who run their own feminine activities which men don’t socially identify with. In the absence of peers or forefathers who modelled the behaviour, the few men who attended ANC felt shy, out-numbered and out of place in a large pool of women who were clapping, singing and dancing to issues that pertain to their pregnancies.The first day I went, I was in a pool of women and all eyes were on me. I was like…OK “what am I doing here?” I am not pregnant! —Male SSI participant, in their 30s. “I am always scared of going for ANC. Imagine being the only man among hundreds of women and the stares you will receive. It makes me feel a type…there are songs that women will be singing, clapping and even dancing to… and they may be expecting you to be clapping and singing as well [laughs]. When you are not clapping because you don’t identify, it becomes a call for concern. When you sing along for solidarity, it is still a call for concern because it may appear as though you are pregnant as well, of which you are not!” —Male SSI participant, in their 30s.

Engendered perception of the time value of ANC attendance

The notion that time is not created equally for men and women in Cameroon emerged as an important factor in this study. Participants reported that the majority of Cameroonian men were primary bread-winners—and being able to provide was a source of masculine identity and pride. This came with the expectation for men to appear busy in income-generating activities. Respondents did not therefore rate ANC attendance as an income-generating activity. They rather perceived it as an opportunity cost—a liability to their bread-winning. Respondents also acknowledged that while ANC attendance was an obligatory activity for women it was often perceived as an optional affair for men who did not wish to spend long hours in ANC clinics.“The point is that coming to the clinic for me is a must. Time or no time I must be at the clinic on the appointed date until delivery. That is not the same for my husband. As a man, he must go out and struggle to work so that he can get something (money) to give me for ANC attendance.” —Female SSI participant, in their 30s. “You have the issue of time…time factor which is also something so important because the man is always busy from morning till night… and remember that it is the man who in most cases (I can say about 80% or 70% of cases), the man is the one who provides everything in the house. So, he makes sure that he catches up with those activities in order to be able to provide. Because when he sits somewhere and loses a day, it is really something big that he has lost” —Male SSI participant, in their 30s.

“Woman Wrapper” stigma—male fear of losing control and female fear of appearing in control

Most Cameroonian men from the North West Region have been conditioned to exercise dominance over women. Since ANC has traditionally been an activity reserved for women, the introduction of men into this space was perceived by study participants as an attempt to usurp their power and relegate men to the background. The mental picture that the majority of participants presented about male ANC attendance was a woman at the forefront and the man behind her as a follower. Men who therefore made attempts to attend ANC clinics were mocked by community members and ridiculed as weaklings who have given up their masculine power or are under metaphysical forces from women.

According to several participants, some Cameroonian phrases or idioms have been coined to label men who are in favour of accompanying their partners for ANC. ‘Woman wrapper’ which literally translates to being too attached and subdued under a woman’s loin cloth was one of such derogatory terms. According to participants, this describes a man who takes orders from his wife or always follows her around.“To add to what my brother has said, let me speak from my community. It appears like, attending ANC with a woman is a way of giving up your authority as a man. When your fellow men see you, they look at you like you are a woman [group laughter]. Yes, you are a woman and not the man because if you were a man, you will not be following your wife to go do women’s things” —Male FGD participant, in their 30s.

The need for men to maintain dominance is so normative in the Cameroonian context to the extent that even women who attended ANC with their partners reflectively defended their partner’s choice in order to distance themselves from any perceived notion that they are controlling their husbands.“ You know, African men have a mentality that if they follow their wives for antenatal care, people might see them and think that he lacks something to do or he is a “woman wrapper” [weakling, sissy or subdued man]…The day we came for ANC, he was the only man who came for ANC and even though some women will think that I am controlling my husband, that was his personal decision” — Female SSI participant, in their 20s.

Limited engagement of men by ANC staff

Health system factors were also thought to limit male participation in antenatal care. Staff and participants who had previously attended ANC opined that the engagement of men by ANC staff was ridden with tokenism which some men find derogatory. Others felt their presence in ANC made no difference because the focus was mostly on their pregnant partners. Sub-themes that emerged from this are explained below:

Token-based engagement (ANC claps for men who attend)

Participants reported that men who were spotted in ANC clinics were given a special ‘ANC clap’ as a form of recognition. While this was generally good-intentioned on the side of service providers, some men received this with mixed feelings. ‘ANC claps’ for men who attended clinics was perceived as an insult to their identity. They felt it reduced them to preschool children who have to be clapped for, for fulfilling the bare minimum of ANC attendance with their wives—something they do not have to be coerced with claps to do.“Some men have said: “I came to the clinic and at the end they said ‘let’s clap for papa, papa came for clinic today’ and they felt like they were in primary school. So they will not come again, because they don’t like being treated as kids” —Staff FGD participant in their 30s.

Lack of male engagement and female-focused health education

Some participants reported that health facilities have not made provision for their presence in ANC clinics. This is evident in the fact that male attendance has not been required and for those who made the effort to attend, providers rarely engaged them. Rather, the entire focus was on their pregnant partners. Some participants substantiated this with the fact that the need for couple attendance is something they only heard about through this study.“You are the first to bring up this procedure on couple ANC attendance and testing for HIV. That is what we should have done before but the attention of the hospital has mostly been on her.” —Male SSI participant, in their 40s.

Intrapersonal Emotions (Fear)

Study participants across FGDs and SSIs echoed the fact that male ANC attendance evokes a range of emotions that serve as barriers to their attendance, including fear. Sub-themes below further expand on these:

Fear of being judged or discovered for extra-marital affairs

Participants mentioned that a pregnant woman in the Cameroonian context is more of an abandoned sexual project and most men use this period to visit their “deuxième bereau”— local lexicon denoting experimentation with extra-marital relationships. They [men] therefore avoided ANC clinics because attending might expose their deeds. A minority of participants equally noted that some aspects of health education during ANC have a judgmental tone that might prick the consciences of men involved in such practices.“Once a woman becomes pregnant, some men get into the practice of what we call ‘side chicks’… they avoid ANC all-together because they don’t want to be judged about their sinful lives and extra-marital affairs. They don’t want health talks at the clinic to echo in their mind and their consciences” —Female SSI participant, in their 30s.

Fear of HIV testing

Male involvement in the Cameroonian context is largely driven by the HIV epidemic and need for PMTCT to the extent that participants associated male ANC attendance with HIV testing. As such, participants reported that men feared attending ANC because they will be required to test for HIV if they came with their pregnant partners.“The ANC testing requirement is also a barrier. Perhaps they are aware that if they come, they will be checked and tested and for those who are unaware/unsure of their status, they don’t want to come” — Male SSI participant, in their 30s. “If a woman is coming for ANC and she tells her husband that they are going to do HIV testing for both of them, at that point you will hear the man say ‘my coming is not necessary’. The name HIV alone cancels the whole issue” —Female SSI participant, in their 20s.

Avoidance of responsibility

In a setting like Cameroon where paternity is rarely established through civil and legal means, male ANC attendance is seen as an explicit form of taking both paternal and financial responsibility and some men want to shy away from this. Additionally, the wide practice of extra-marital affairs during pregnancy probably resulted in pregnancies that most men did not want to be publicly associated with through ANC attendance.“I think there is also a financial barrier. Some men don’t want to attend ANC because attending will mean they are taking responsibility as authors of the pregnancy and this also means they are required to show up as fathers and engage in financial responsibilities” —Male SSI participant, in their 30s. “Some men are ashamed especially when they have impregnated many girls in the neighbourhood and they don’t want to be tagged as a particular woman’s husband when there are other women he has impregnated and he is denying being responsibility for their pregnancies.” —Female SSI participant, in their 20s.